Legal and Technical Analysis of Active Sports Management Pty Ltd and Industry Innovation and Science Australia [2023] AATA 4078

Media coverage of business response to proposed R&D Tax Changes announced in May Budget

1. Executive Summary and Case Background

1.1 Overview of the Dispute and Procedural History

The decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) in Active Sports Management Pty Ltd and Industry Innovation and Science Australia [2023] AATA 4078, handed down on 6 December 2023 by Senior Member Adria Poljak, stands as a definitive modern authority on the evidentiary and methodological thresholds governing Australia’s Research and Development Tax Incentive (RDTI) regime1. The dispute arose from applications lodged by Active Sports Management Pty Ltd (ASM), trading as Peak Sport Australia, to register specific footwear development activities for the 2015–16 and 2016–17 income years3. Following a statutory examination and subsequent internal review, the respondent regulator, Industry Innovation and Science Australia (IISA)—operating through AusIndustry within the Department of Industry, Science and Resources (DISR)—determined that none of the registered tasks constituted eligible core R&D activities or supporting R&D activities3. The Tribunal’s reasons do not record any assessment action by the Commissioner of Taxation; the decision under review was IISA’s internal review decision of 8 November 2019, which confirmed IISA’s determination of 6 May 2019 under section 27J of the IR&D Act that the claimed activities were neither core nor supporting R&D activities (at [5]–[6])6.

ASM applied to the AAT for merits review of IISA’s internal review decision, contending that its iterative design, prototyping, and performance testing of a bespoke basketball shoe satisfied the statutory criteria for eligible R&D3. On 6 December 2023, the Tribunal affirmed IISA’s decision in its entirety, holding that ASM had failed to establish that the outcomes of the claimed activities could not have been known or determined in advance, failed to demonstrate a systematic progression of work based on principles of established science (there being no contemporaneous evidence that the asserted hypotheses were formulated before any prototype was manufactured or tested), and failed to establish that the activities were conducted for the purpose of generating new knowledge (at [37], [40], [52], [56])1. ASM subsequently appealed the Tribunal’s decision to the Federal Court of Australia on questions of law8. On 25 November 2024, in Active Sports Management Pty Ltd v Industry Innovation and Science Australia [2024] FCA 1346, the Federal Court dismissed the taxpayer’s appeal and ordered ASM to pay the respondent’s legal costs, having found that the Tribunal had conducted the review it was required to conduct and had not misconstrued subsection 355-25(1), and noting that in any event the Tribunal’s independent findings on the second limb of paragraph 355-25(1)(a) and on paragraph 355-25(1)(b) would stand10.

1.2 Factual Matrix and the Taxpayer’s Claim

Active Sports Management Pty Ltd operates as the Australian commercial distributor and product development partner for Peak Sport, designing and developing sporting apparel and footwear tailored to the Australian market or incorporating unique Australian stylistic and functional attributes3. During the 2015–16 and 2016–17 income years, ASM undertook a commercial project to create the “Delly1”, a signature customised basketball shoe engineered specifically for the biomechanical requirements, playing style, and personal preferences of Australian Olympian and National Basketball Association (NBA) champion Matthew Dellavedova3.

To access the R&D tax offset under Division 355 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth) (ITAA 1997), ASM applied to IISA under section 27A of the Industry Research and Development Act 1986 (Cth) (IR&D Act) to register three purported core R&D activities across the two relevant income years3. Those registered core activities were designated in the registration applications as “Prototyping for tests and experiments”, “Tests and experiments”, and “Other tests and experiments” (Activities 1.1 and 1.2 for both income years, and Activity 1.3 for the 2016–17 income year only), all registered as core R&D activities (at [3])3. ASM asserted that the development of the Delly1 shoe required extensive time and resources, involving the fabrication of six distinct physical shoe prototypes, numerous structural revisions, and multiple functional failures before arriving at the final commercial design6. In support of its claim before the Tribunal, ASM relied on statements of its sole director, Mr Gregory Bickley, annexing a retrospective “Delly1 Prototype Development History” covering the six prototypes, together with photographs of each prototype, videos of Mr Dellavedova’s feedback on Prototype 3, a video of Prototype 4 that the Tribunal found was plainly taken for promotional purposes, WeChat messages (June–July and October 2016) and two emails from Mr Dellavedova’s manager to PEAK (August and September 2016) concerning Prototype 4, emails from two players written in April 2023, and the expert evidence of Dr Peter Ellerton (at [25]–[29], [43])6. Notably, the prototypes were manufactured by Quanzhou Peak Shoes Co, Ltd (PEAK) in China, while wear testing took place in training sessions and NBA training camps in Australia and the United States; the Tribunal’s reasons make no reference to an Overseas Finding and do not decide any issue concerning overseas activities (at [22], [24], [26])6.

1.3 Governing Australian Statutory Framework

The Australian RDTI operates under a bifurcated, co-regulatory statutory architecture jointly administered by IISA (supported by DISR and AusIndustry) and the Commissioner of Taxation (ATO)5. While the calculation and claiming of the refundable or non-refundable tax offset occur through the self-assessment income tax return mechanism overseen by the ATO under Division 355 of the ITAA 1997, the threshold determination of whether claimed technical tasks constitute eligible R&D activities sits within the jurisdiction of IISA under Part III of the IR&D Act5. Under section 27A of the IR&D Act, an R&D entity must register its R&D activities annually with IISA within ten months after the end of its income year10. Registration under section 27A is an administrative prerequisite to claiming the tax offset, not a substantive approval of eligibility5. Under Division 3 of Part III of the IR&D Act, IISA is empowered to examine a registration and make formal findings as to whether registered activities were core R&D activities or supporting R&D activities, which bind the Commissioner of Taxation for the purposes of assessing the entity’s entitlement to a tax offset under section 355-100 of the ITAA 19973.

The substantive legal definitions governing activity eligibility are codified in Subdivision 355-B of the ITAA 19976. Section 355-20 establishes that R&D activities are categorised exclusively as either “core R&D activities” or “supporting R&D activities”3. Pursuant to subsection 355-25(1) of the ITAA 1997, core R&D activities are defined via a cumulative two-limb statutory test10. Under paragraph 355-25(1)(a), the activities must be experimental activities whose outcome cannot be known or determined in advance on the basis of current knowledge, information or experience, but can only be determined by applying a systematic progression of work that is based on principles of established science and proceeds from hypothesis to experiment, observation and evaluation, and leads to logical conclusions3. Under paragraph 355-25(1)(b), those experimental activities must be conducted for the purpose of generating new knowledge, including new knowledge in the form of new or improved materials, products, devices, processes or services6. Subsection 355-25(2) sets out specific statutory exclusions—such as market research, market testing or market development, management studies or efficiency surveys, research in social sciences, arts or humanities, and activities related to the reproduction of a commercial product or process—which are deemed not to be core R&D activities even if they otherwise satisfy subsection 355-25(1); in Active Sports Management the Tribunal identified only the market research exclusion as potentially relevant and did not need to apply it (at [14])21.

Supporting R&D activities are defined under section 355-30 of the ITAA 1997 as activities directly related to core R&D activities3. However, if a supporting activity falls within the exclusions listed in subsection 355-25(2), or if it produces, or is directly related to producing, goods or services for commercial supply, subsection 355-30(2) mandates that the activity must be undertaken for the dominant purpose of supporting core R&D activities15. Furthermore, under section 355-210 of the ITAA 1997 and section 28C of the IR&D Act, R&D activities must be conducted solely within Australia unless the R&D entity holds a valid Overseas Finding determination issued by IISA confirming that the overseas activities cannot be conducted in Australia, have a significant scientific link to Australian core R&D activities, and involve less expenditure than the Australian core activities6.

1.4 The Tribunal’s Final Holding and Judicial Affirmation

In Active Sports Management [2023] AATA 4078, Senior Member Poljak held that ASM failed to discharge its statutory onus of proof to establish that any of the claimed tasks satisfied subsection 355-25(1) of the ITAA 19973. The Tribunal determined that ASM’s development of the Delly1 basketball shoe was fundamentally an exercise in product customisation and iterative trial-and-error refinement designed to satisfy the subjective personal preferences or requirements of an individual athlete (at [33], [57]), rather than a scientific investigation resolving genuine technical uncertainty6. Because none of the claimed tasks qualified as eligible core R&D activities under section 355-25, the Tribunal necessarily held that none of the ancillary tasks could qualify as supporting R&D activities under section 355-30, as supporting eligibility is strictly derivative of a valid core activity3. When ASM sought judicial review before the Federal Court in Active Sports Management [2024] FCA 1346, alleging that the Tribunal had failed to conduct the review it was required to conduct (including by adopting the respondent’s submissions) and had misconstrued subsection 355-25(1), Goodman J found no error of law in the Tribunal’s decision and dismissed the appeal with costs on 25 November 202410.

2. Core Legal and Evidentiary Failures

2.1 Absence of Ex-Ante Hypotheses and Reliance on Trial-and-Error Methodology

The foundational legal failure in ASM’s claim was its inability to satisfy the methodological mandate of paragraph 355-25(1)(a) of the ITAA 1997, which requires a systematic progression of work based on principles of established science proceeding sequentially from hypothesis to experiment, observation, evaluation, and logical conclusions3. Senior Member Poljak emphasised that the formulation of a valid scientific or technical hypothesis is the indispensable starting point of any eligible core R&D activity, as it defines the specific causal proposition under investigation and identifies the precise technical outcome sought to be achieved6. To satisfy Division 355, a hypothesis must be articulated ex-ante—that is, before the physical manufacturing, prototyping, or experimental testing commences6.

In scrutinising ASM’s evidence regarding the six prototypes of the Delly1 shoe, the Tribunal found a complete absence of contemporaneous documentation demonstrating that any scientific hypothesis had been formulated prior to fabricating or testing the prototypes6. While ASM demonstrated that it had constructed multiple prototypes and subjected them to wear testing by the athlete, the Tribunal observed that repeated prototyping, functional testing, identification of design flaws, and iterative modification do not, without more, constitute experimental activities under section 355-257. Rather than designing controlled, repeatable, and verifiable experiments capable of isolating the biomechanical or material effects of specific structural modifications made to the shoe, ASM engaged in an unstructured “trial-and-error” exercise6. When the athlete reported discomfort or performance dissatisfaction with a prototype, adjustments were made to subsequent iterations without isolating variables or testing a falsifiable scientific proposition6. The Tribunal characterised this workflow as a general problem-solving and knowledge-discovery process—akin to standard commercial product engineering refinement—rather than a scientific process governed by Division 35519.

2.2 Failure to Establish Technical Uncertainty and the Competent Professional Standard

Closely linked to the absence of structured experimentation was ASM’s failure to satisfy the threshold epistemological test in paragraph 355-25(1)(a): proving that the outcome of the claimed activities could not be known or determined in advance on the basis of current knowledge, information, or experience6. Under established Australian RDTI jurisprudence, this inquiry is objective and assessed by reference to a hypothetical “competent professional” possessing the relevant scientific or technical qualifications and access to publicly available knowledge in the pertinent field6. It is insufficient that the taxpayer’s internal personnel or commercial designers did not personally know whether a specific shoe configuration would satisfy the athlete’s performance requirements6.

The Tribunal found that ASM’s supporting documentation failed to specify the exact physical, chemical, or structural modifications made across the six shoe prototypes, and provided no objective technical evidence explaining why the functional behaviour of those modifications could not have been predicted in advance by a competent footwear engineer or sports biomechanist6. This aspect of the ruling aligns directly with the broader line of Australian tribunal and judicial authority—including PKWK and Innovation and Science Australia (Taxation) [2021], Coal of Queensland Pty Ltd v Innovation and Science Australia [2021], Camalic Pty Ltd and Innovation and Science Australia [2020], Lakes Oil NL and Innovation and Science Australia [2023], Body by Michael Pty Ltd and Industry Innovation and Science Australia [2025] ARTA 44, and Ultimate Vision Inventions Pty Ltd v Industry Innovation and Science Australia [2025]—which holds that operational complexity, commercial difficulty, and variability in system performance do not equate to scientific or technical uncertainty5. The Tribunal itself relied on Coal of Queensland v Innovation and Science Australia (2021) 285 FCR 286 at [101] for the proposition that, although the precise data produced by the work could not have been known in advance, it does not follow that the outcome could not have been known or determined in advance (at [32]). A complex mechanical or biomechanical system may exhibit variable performance under real-world athletic conditions without involving any unknown underlying scientific principles19. Where a project merely navigates known engineering trade-offs or resolves practical fabrication challenges using established techniques, no statutory technical uncertainty exists6.

2.3 Mischaracterisation of Bespoke Customisation as New Knowledge Generation

Under paragraph 355-25(1)(b) of the ITAA 1997, an experimental activity is only eligible if it is conducted for the purpose of generating new knowledge6. The Tribunal held that ASM’s activities failed this purposive test because the work was directed toward modifying and applying existing footwear design knowledge to accommodate the idiosyncratic anatomical requirements, playing style, and subjective comfort preferences of a single professional basketball player6.

In Australian RDTI law, there is a fundamental doctrinal distinction between generating new scientific or technical knowledge and applying existing knowledge to a new commercial context or bespoke product specification6. Tuning, optimising, or reconfiguring known materials and structural components to improve the performance of an existing system—whether a basketball shoe, an industrial coal processing plant, or a software algorithm—does not generate new knowledge within the meaning of paragraph 355-25(1)(b) unless the optimisation requires resolving a fundamental scientific unknown19. By conflating product personalisation and iterative design refinement with scientific research, ASM attempted to bring routine commercial product development within a statutory regime strictly reserved for genuine experimental inquiry5.

2.4 Evidentiary Deficiencies, Retrospective Reconstruction, and the Rix’s Creek Principle

The dispute in Active Sports Management highlights the severe evidentiary consequences of inadequate contemporaneous record-keeping in Australian tax litigation5. In merits review proceedings before the AAT (and its statutory successor, the Administrative Review Tribunal (ART)), the Tribunal must itself be satisfied on the evidence that the statutory criteria of Division 355 are met, so in practice the applicant must adduce evidence establishing each element; in Active Sports Management the Tribunal was repeatedly “not satisfied” that those elements were established (at [52], [56])14. To discharge this burden, ASM relied heavily on a patchwork of informal digital artefacts—specifically emails, WeChat instant messages, photographs, and videos—supplemented by oral witness testimony and a retrospective summary document describing the six shoe prototypes6.

In assessing this evidence, Senior Member Poljak relied on the Tribunal’s earlier decision in Rix’s Creek Pty Ltd; Bloomfield Collieries Pty Ltd and Innovation Australia [2017] AATA 645, acknowledging that the creation and provision of documentation is not a statutory requirement to substantiate R&D activities, while emphasising that documentary evidence is an expected feature of an activity that is systematic, investigative and experimental (at [19]); the Tribunal’s reasons do not cite Commissioner of Taxation v Bogiatto [2020] FCA 1139, which was an R&D promoter penalty proceeding7. However, the Tribunal underscored that contemporaneous written evidence detailing the process of each activity will be highly persuasive, and that an absence of documentation where more extensive documentation would ordinarily be expected may suggest that section 355-25 has not been satisfied, citing Lakes Oil NL and Innovation and Science Australia [2023] AATA 811 at [219] (at [17]–[18])5. Consistent with this, the Tribunal gave little weight to retrospective material: the players’ emails of April 2023 were not contemporaneous, recalled events at least six years after testing and conflicted with Mr Bickley’s evidence, and the Tribunal identified a “relevant and substantial inconsistency” in the evidence about whether Prototype 1 started largely from an existing PEAK product (at [29], [31])5. ASM’s WeChat logs, emails, and photographs proved only that commercial communications occurred and that physical shoe samples were produced and worn; they failed entirely to record what was scientifically known and unknown at the time, what specific hypothesis was being tested in each prototype, what quantitative metrics were observed, or how variables were isolated5.

2.5 Extraterritorial Fragmentation, Contractual Nexus, and Supporting Activity Disqualification

A further structural feature of ASM’s claim, although not one on which the Tribunal’s decision turned, was the geographic and contractual fragmentation of its supply chain6. Because ASM operated as the Australian partner of Peak Sport, all six shoe prototypes were manufactured overseas by Quanzhou Peak Shoes Co, Ltd (PEAK) in China, while the wear testing took place in Australia and the United States, including at NBA training camps (at [22], [24], [26])4. Under Australian RDTI law, expenditure on activities conducted outside Australia is strictly ineligible unless the taxpayer applies for and obtains a positive Overseas Finding from IISA under section 28C of the IR&D Act before the end of the income year in which the activities are conducted6. The Tribunal’s reasons do not record whether ASM held or applied for an Overseas Finding, and the Tribunal made no finding under section 28C of the IR&D Act or section 355-210 of the ITAA 1997; its decision rested entirely on subsection 355-25(1) (at [57])6.

As demonstrated in Australian tribunal and Federal Court jurisprudence—such as the T.D.S BIZ litigation [2022] regarding unapproved overseas moulds and assembly, and reinforced by ATO Taxpayer Alerts TA 2023/4 and TA 2023/5—performing key phases of prototyping and testing offshore creates a dual compliance hazard6. First, the offshore expenditure itself is statutorily excluded without a section 28C finding6. Second, and even more fatally for the domestic claim, if the experimental testing and evaluation phases are outsourced overseas while only conceptual design occurs in Australia, the taxpayer fails to conduct a complete core R&D activity within Australia6. For an Australian activity to qualify as a core R&D activity without an Overseas Finding, the entire systematic progression—from hypothesis formulation to experimentation, observation, evaluation, and logical conclusion—must be demonstrably executed in Australia6. Furthermore, because ASM failed to establish the existence of any eligible core R&D activity under section 355-25, the Tribunal held that none of the Claimed Activities, including Activity 1.1 (“Prototyping for tests and experiments”), could be supporting R&D activities under subsection 355-30(1) (at [57])3. Without an anchor core R&D activity, no activity can satisfy the “directly related” test of subsection 355-30(1) or the “dominant purpose” test of subsection 355-30(2)3.

3. Comparative Summary Table

The following table maps each statutory requirement examined in Active Sports Management Pty Ltd and Industry Innovation and Science Australia [2023] AATA 4078 (and affirmed in [2024] FCA 1346) against the taxpayer’s evidentiary submission, the specific legal and technical failure identified by the Tribunal, and the governing Australian standard of proof6.

 

Statutory Provision & Legal Requirement Taxpayer’s Claim & Evidentiary Submission Identified Legal & Technical Failure Tribunal & Federal Court Standard of Proof
ITAA 1997 s 355-25(1)(a): Formulation of an Ex-Ante Hypothesis Relied on asserted hypotheses recorded in the retrospective Development History (for example, testing whether each prototype “would meet Matthew’s requirements”), and on Dr Ellerton’s opinion that a hypothesis must have been developed at some stage (at [39], [43])6. Complete absence of contemporaneous evidence showing a hypothesis was formulated before manufacturing or testing any of the prototypes6. A hypothesis takes its ordinary meaning but must have a scientific basis; contemporaneous evidence that it was formulated before manufacture or testing is especially important, and statements of objectives or descriptions of what was done (as Dr Sterzing characterised ASM’s asserted hypotheses) are not hypotheses (at [38], [40], [42])6.
ITAA 1997 s 355-25(1)(a): Systematic Progression of Work Based on Established Science Relied on emails, WeChat logs, photos, videos, and a summary of six prototypes to show repeated cycles of fabrication, wear testing, failure, and revision6. Workflow was characterised as an unscientific “trial-and-error” and problem-solving exercise incapable of isolating the causal effects of specific modifications6. Experimentation must follow a repeatable, verifiable scientific methodology grounded in established scientific principles that systematically isolates variables, measures quantitative observations, and evaluates results against the initial hypothesis3.
ITAA 1997 s 355-25(1)(a): Outcome Cannot Be Known or Determined in Advance (Technical Uncertainty) Asserted that because the shoe required multiple revisions and failures to meet an NBA player’s rigorous demands, the outcome was uncertain at the outset6. Documentation failed to identify exact physical modifications or prove why a competent professional could not predict their outcome using existing biomechanical and footwear knowledge6. Uncertainty is judged objectively by the standard of a competent professional in the relevant field; system complexity, operational variability, or commercial difficulty does not establish scientific or technical uncertainty6.
ITAA 1997 s 355-25(1)(b): Purpose of Generating New Knowledge Contended that the Delly1, the first genuine “signature shoe” in Australia, was a new and improved shoe that generated new knowledge, including through the 3D-printed KPU mesh upper (at [21], [55])3. Activities merely modified previously known athletic shoe design features to suit the personal preferences or requirements of an individual athlete, relying on PEAK’s existing knowledge; the mesh upper was developed by PEAK and was not shown to form part of the Claimed Activities (at [54]–[55], [57])6. The activities must be conducted for the purpose of generating new knowledge, meaning knowledge not already publicly available on a reasonably accessible worldwide basis, going beyond a simple progression from what is known or the implementation of existing knowledge in a different context (at [13], [53]–[54])6.
ITAA 1997 s 355-30(1) & (2): Supporting R&D Activities & Dominant Purpose Registered prototype fabrication (Activity 1.1, “Prototyping for tests and experiments”) as a core R&D activity; IISA’s internal review decision found that none of the Claimed Activities were core or supporting R&D activities (at [3], [6], [24])3. Because no eligible core R&D activities were established under s 355-25, no ancillary or prototyping activities could be “directly related” to or have the “dominant purpose” of supporting a core activity3. Supporting activities are strictly derivative; the taxpayer must first prove the existence of a valid core R&D activity and, for production or excluded activities, prove via objective evidence that supporting the core experiment was the prevailing, ruling purpose3.
IR&D Act 1986 s 28C & ITAA 1997 s 355-210: Overseas Activities & Australian Core Nexus Prototypes were manufactured offshore by PEAK in China as part of the Peak Sport supply chain, with wear testing in Australia and the United States; the reasons do not record whether an Overseas Finding was held or sought (at [22], [24], [26])6. Not determined by the Tribunal: the decision rested solely on s 355-25(1), and no finding was made under s 28C or s 355-210 (at [57]); the overseas risk arises from the general statutory framework rather than from this ruling6. Not a standard applied in this case; under the general statutory framework, expenditure on overseas activities can be claimed only where a s 28C Overseas Finding covers those activities (see T.D.S BIZ)6.
Merits Review of IISA’s Internal Review Decision & Evidentiary Substantiation (Rix’s Creek Principle) Adduced Mr Bickley’s statements and oral evidence, Dr Ellerton’s expert report, informal digital messages (WeChat, emails), a retrospective prototype Development History and players’ emails written in April 2023 to fill gaps in formal technical records (at [25]–[29], [43])6. Failed to discharge the statutory onus of proof; informal communications and ex-post recollections could not establish ex-ante hypotheses or scientific rigour5. While the creation of documentation is not a statutory requirement (Rix’s Creek [2017] AATA 645 at [21]), documentary evidence is an expected feature of systematic experimental work, its absence may suggest s 355-25 is not satisfied (Lakes Oil [2023] AATA 811 at [219]), and contemporaneous written evidence is highly persuasive (at [17]–[19])5.

4. Two Applied Remedial Case Studies

4.1 Case Study 1: Advanced Polymer Composite Footwear and Offshore Contract Moulding

Project Scenario and Inherent Legal Pitfalls

KangaStride Biomechanics Pty Ltd (KangaStride), an Australian sports technology company based in Melbourne, is developing an impact-attenuating metamaterial midsole (“KangaCell-X”) designed to reduce lower-limb ground reaction forces for elite professional netball and basketball athletes. KangaStride employs two industrial designers in Australia and contracts an associated manufacturing factory in Dongguan, China, to injection-mould six sequential footwear prototypes using thermoplastic polyurethane (TPU) and supercritical nitrogen foaming. The Australian designers communicate structural adjustments to the factory via WeChat and email, and two professional athletes wear-test the prototypes during training sessions in Melbourne, providing verbal feedback on comfort, court feel, and stability.

Under the legal principles established in Active Sports Management [2023] AATA 4078 and affirmed in [2024] FCA 1346, KangaStride’s project faces total disqualification under Division 355 of the ITAA 19976. First, relying on subjective athlete feedback (“comfort” and “court feel”) to drive iterative adjustments across six prototypes will be characterised by IISA and the ART as an unscientific trial-and-error customisation process rather than a systematic progression of work based on established science6. Second, communicating design tweaks via WeChat and email without prior literature reviews or formal experimental protocols fails to establish an ex-ante scientific hypothesis or prove that a competent polymer chemist or biomechanist could not determine the outcome in advance6. Third, and separately from the principles applied in Active Sports Management (which did not decide any overseas-activity issue), outsourcing prototype fabrication and material stress-testing to an associated Chinese manufacturer without an Overseas Finding under section 28C of the IR&D Act places the offshore expenditure outside the incentive, fragments the core R&D activity across jurisdictions, and may attract ATO scrutiny under Taxpayer Alerts TA 2023/4 (associated entities) and TA 2023/5 (overseas R&D)6.

Step 1: Restructuring Project Governance and Stage-Gate Architecture

To insulate the claim against regulatory challenge, KangaStride must dismantle its informal commercial design workflow and establish a formal R&D Governance Charter overseen by an internal Technical Steering Committee prior to the commencement of the income year5. The Charter must legally and operationally segregate routine commercial footwear styling, aesthetic customisation, and athlete fitting (which are excluded business-as-usual activities) from the experimental metamaterial midsole investigation5. KangaStride must implement a mandatory Stage-Gate protocol where no prototype tooling or moulding expenditure can be authorised until Gate 1 (Literature Review & Competent Professional Sign-Off) and Gate 2 (Formal Hypothesis & Experimental Test Plan Approval) are signed and date-stamped by the Lead Biomechanical Engineer5. Separate general ledger cost centres must be established in the accounting system to capture eligible R&D labour, domestic laboratory testing consumables, and eligible supporting prototyping costs distinctly from commercial marketing and athlete endorsement expenses5.

Step 2: Technical Documentation and Ex-Ante Hypothesis Formulation

Before fabricating Prototype 1, KangaStride’s qualified materials engineer must author a formal Baseline State of Knowledge and Technical Uncertainty Dossier5. This document must survey peer-reviewed polymer science literature and existing footwear patents to demonstrate objectively why a competent professional cannot predict how a specific auxetic lattice geometry combined with a 15% supercritical nitrogen-infused TPU blend will behave under multi-directional shear loads exceeding 6. Specifically, the dossier must articulate the exact scientific tension: namely, that under established polymer physics, decreasing cell wall thickness below to achieve a negative Poisson’s ratio induces premature elastic buckling under lateral court cuts, and existing finite element models fail to predict the non-linear viscoelastic recovery rate when blended with secondary elastomer modifiers6.

Grounded in this documented uncertainty, KangaStride must record an explicit, falsifiable ex-ante hypothesis prior to each experimental cycle6. For example: “It is hypothesised that modifying the auxetic re-entrant cell angle of the supercritical TPU midsole to while cross-linking with dicumyl peroxide will maintain a peak vertical impact attenuation above at impact velocity while increasing lateral shear modulus by without cell-wall delamination, because the peroxide cross-linking reinforces the inter-crystalline tie molecules at the hinge vertices.” This transforms the activity from subjective athlete customisation into a rigorous scientific inquiry aimed at generating new, generalisable materials engineering knowledge under paragraph 355-25(1)(b)6.

Step 3: Contractual Terms, IP Ownership, and Extraterritorial Structuring

To address the overseas manufacturing risk illustrated by T.D.S BIZ (an issue the Tribunal did not determine in Active Sports Management, although the Delly1 prototypes were manufactured by PEAK in China), KangaStride must restructure its contractual and operational relationship with the Chinese factory6. Rather than allowing the offshore factory to conduct material formulation adjustments and mechanical testing in China, KangaStride must ensure that a complete, self-contained core R&D activity occurs wholly within Australia6. All finite element modelling, hypothesis formulation, mechanical rig testing, observation, quantitative evaluation, and logical conclusion drawing must be performed exclusively at KangaStride’s Melbourne biomechanics laboratory3.

If the physical injection moulding of the experimental midsole blanks is performed by a contractor, KangaStride should ideally engage an Australian-based additive manufacturing or polymer moulding facility so the expenditure qualifies domestically as a supporting R&D activity under section 355-306. If KangaStride must use the offshore facility solely to fabricate the raw physical test coupons to KangaStride’s exact CAD specifications, KangaStride must either lodge an Overseas Finding application with IISA under section 28C of the IR&D Act before the end of the income year (proving that required supercritical nitrogen tooling does not exist in Australia), or wholly exclude the offshore moulding invoices from its R&D expenditure calculation while preserving the eligibility of its domestic Australian testing activities6. Furthermore, the Master Services Agreement (MSA) and each Statement of Work (SOW) with any domestic fabrication contractor must explicitly state that the prototypes are fabricated for the dominant purpose of destructive and non-destructive experimental testing in support of Core R&D Activity 1.1, have zero commercial resale value, and vest all foreground intellectual property and risk exclusively in KangaStride in compliance with the “at-risk” and “conducted for” rules in sections 355-210 and 355-405 of the ITAA 19975.

Step 4: Experimentation Tracking and Variable Isolation Protocols

To eliminate the “trial-and-error” finding in Active Sports Management, KangaStride must replace athlete wear-testing and WeChat feedback with a controlled, repeatable laboratory testing protocol capable of isolating individual independent variables6. Between Prototype 1 and Prototype 6, only one independent variable (such as cell vertex angle or crosslinking density) may be altered per experimental run, holding polymer base, ambient temperature , and midsole thickness strictly constant6. Testing must be executed on an Instron electro-dynamic mechanical testing rig and an AMTI 6-degree-of-freedom force plate in Melbourne, capturing quantitative dependent variables (hysteresis energy loss in Joules, peak G-force deceleration, and cycles to structural fatigue failure) in an immutable Electronic Laboratory Notebook (ELN)5. If human athletes are subsequently used for biomechanical validation, they must be instrumented with 3D optical motion-capture markers and in-shoe pressure-mapping insoles under an ethics-approved protocol to measure objective kinematic data rather than subjective comfort preferences2.

 

Remediation Dimension Deficient Practice (ASM Baseline) Restructured Compliant Practice (KangaStride Protocol) Statutory & Judicial Authority Satisfied
Hypothesis & Uncertainty Informal design goals to improve shoe comfort and performance for an individual player6. Formal ex-ante scientific hypothesis linking auxetic lattice angle and crosslinking density to shear modulus, backed by a competent professional literature review6. ITAA 1997 s 355-25(1)(a) & (b); Active Sports Management [2023] AATA 40786.
Experimental Methodology Unstructured trial-and-error wear testing across six prototypes with multiple simultaneous design tweaks6. Controlled single-variable isolation across prototypes using calibrated Instron mechanical testing rigs and force plates in Australia6. ITAA 1997 s 355-25(1)(a); Ultimate Vision Inventions [2025]6.
Evidentiary Architecture Fragmented WeChat logs, emails, photos, videos, and retrospective prototype summaries5. Time-stamped Electronic Laboratory Notebooks (ELN), stage-gate sign-offs, raw telemetry data logs, and variance evaluation reports5. Rix’s Creek [2017] AATA 645; Lakes Oil NL [2023] AATA 811 at [219]; Active Sports Management [2023] AATA 4078 at [17]–[19]7.
Extraterritorial & Contractual Nexus Prototypes manufactured offshore by PEAK in China (the Tribunal made no finding on any s 28C Overseas Finding)6. Complete core R&D cycle executed onshore in Melbourne; domestic SOWs specifying dominant purpose under s 355-30(2), or prior s 28C Overseas Finding obtained6. IR&D Act 1986 s 28C; ITAA 1997 s 355-30 & s 355-210; T.D.S BIZ [2022]6.

4.2 Case Study 2: Industrial Sensor and Predictive Algorithm Optimisation in Variable Environments

Project Scenario and Inherent Legal Pitfalls

TerraPulse Analytics Pty Ltd (TerraPulse), an Australian industrial automation and software engineering firm in Brisbane, is developing an acoustic and hyperspectral optical sorting system designed to detect internal sub-surface defects in bulk mineral ores moving along a high-speed conveyor belt at . Because raw mineral ore exhibits extreme natural variability in moisture, surface dust, and geometry, TerraPulse’s software engineers spend eighteen months iteratively adjusting convolutional neural network (CNN) hyperparameters, acoustic signal filters, and sensor mounting angles across hundreds of test runs at a client’s mine site. The engineers track their daily coding tasks via standard Jira tickets and Slack messages, and at year-end, an external R&D consultant interviews the lead developer to draft a retrospective technical summary claiming the entire eighteen-month software and hardware tuning effort as a core R&D activity.

This scenario directly triggers the doctrinal traps articulated in Active Sports Management and its companion Division 355 authorities (PKWK, Coal of Queensland, and Lakes Oil NL)19. As the Tribunal and Federal Court jurisprudence confirms, complexity does not equal experimentation, and variability does not equal technical uncertainty19. Tuning software algorithms, adjusting signal filters, and re-orienting known hardware sensors to cope with variable natural environments or raw material characteristics is classified by IISA as routine system optimisation and engineering refinement of a known system, not experimental investigation of unknown scientific principles19. Furthermore, relying on routine Jira tickets, Slack messages, and a consultant’s retrospective narrative mirrors the exact evidentiary failure in Active Sports Management, where informal communications and ex-post summaries failed to prove ex-ante hypotheses or systematic variable isolation5. Finally, testing on a live client conveyor belt without clear contractual separation risks characterisation as commercial commissioning or quality control excluded under subsection 355-25(2), or breaches the dominant purpose test under subsection 355-30(2)5.

Step 1: Restructuring Project Governance and R&D Committee Charter

To transform its compliance posture, TerraPulse must institute a formal Software & Mechatronics R&D Compliance Framework prior to project initiation5. The framework must enforce a strict demarcation between standard software engineering tasks—such as data pipeline ingestion, user interface development, bug fixing, hardware mounting, and hyperparameter grid-search tuning (which must be excluded as business-as-usual optimisation)—and genuine experimental computer science research5. TerraPulse must establish a fortnightly R&D Review Board chaired by its Chief Technology Officer (a PhD in signal processing)7. Under the Board’s governance charter, an engineering sprint can only be tagged with an R&D project code in the timesheet and payroll ledger if it is linked to an active, pre-approved Experimental Protocol Document (EPD) that defines a fundamental algorithmic or physical signal-propagation uncertainty5. Time spent by engineers on routine site installation or commercial calibration is routed to a commercial cost centre, establishing a defensible, contemporaneous apportionment methodology that satisfies ATO audit standards5.

Step 2: Technical Documentation and Competent Professional Baseline Establishment

Rather than claiming that the variability of wet mineral ore makes the sorting outcome unpredictable, TerraPulse must document an objective scientific unknown at the level of fundamental physics and computational mathematics16. Prior to writing code, the CTO must compile a Competent Professional Technical Baseline Report documenting why existing state-of-the-art multispectral fusion algorithms cannot resolve phase-shift signal attenuation when acoustic ultrasonic pulses interact with non-Newtonian clay layers on irregular mineral surfaces5. The report must cite academic signal-processing literature showing that standard Fast Fourier Transform (FFT) denoising and conventional CNN architectures suffer catastrophic latency and false-positive rates due to multi-path acoustic scattering, and that no known mathematical method exists to decouple surface moisture refraction from sub-surface density anomalies in real time under 5.

From this baseline, TerraPulse must formulate and document a precise ex-ante hypothesis before commencing coding6: “It is hypothesised that replacing standard spatial convolution layers with a novel complex-valued wavelet-transform neural network incorporating a physics-informed acoustic attenuation loss function will isolate sub-surface density reflections from surface moisture scattering, achieving classification accuracy at an inference latency of per ore fragment.” This shifts the legal characterisation of the project from routine algorithm parameter tuning to the generation of new computational science knowledge under section 355-2510.

Step 3: Contractual Terms, Site Access Agreements, and Contractor SOWs

Because TerraPulse conducts validation trials using ore samples from a commercial mining client, it must eliminate any ambiguity regarding commercial production, feedstock, or “conducted for” exclusions5. TerraPulse must execute a standalone R&D Experimental Site Access and Bailment Agreement with the mining client, wholly separate from any commercial equipment supply contract5. The agreement must stipulate that TerraPulse bears 100% of the financial and technical risk of the experimental trials (receiving no guaranteed fee for the experimental work), retains exclusive legal and beneficial ownership of all foreground algorithmic IP generated, and constructs a dedicated, off-line bypass test loop rather than sorting commercial production ore on the main plant line16. This ensures that the construction and operation of the bypass test rig satisfies the “dominant purpose” test for supporting R&D activities under subsection 355-30(2) of the ITAA 1997, rather than being disqualified as commercial production or commissioning16. Similarly, any external data-science contractors engaged by TerraPulse must be bound by Statements of Work that explicitly reference the pre-approved Experimental Protocol Document, require the delivery of raw experimental test logs as a condition of invoice payment, and itemise R&D hours separately from commercial software maintenance5.

Step 4: Experimentation Tracking, Repeatable Test Harnesses, and Contemporaneous Data Logging

To overcome the evidentiary criticisms in Active Sports Management regarding informal messaging and trial-and-error testing, TerraPulse must implement an automated, reproducible experimental test harness5. Instead of ad-hoc adjustments on a live conveyor belt where ore moisture and geometry fluctuate randomly, TerraPulse must first test its hypotheses against a controlled, synthetic benchmark dataset and a laboratory conveyor loop utilising 500 calibrated mineral reference standards with known, pre-measured internal voids and controlled moisture films (, , , and saturation)6.

Every experimental run must be logged automatically via an MLOps tracking platform (such as MLflow integrated with Git) that links each code commit directly to a specific Hypothesis ID5. The system must automatically record the exact independent variable modified (e.g., wavelet mother function or physics-loss weight ), the immutable input dataset version, the quantitative observation metrics (inference latency in milliseconds, precision-recall curves, and signal-to-noise ratio in decibels), and a contemporaneous written evaluation by the lead researcher explaining why the experimental results confirmed or falsified the hypothesis and what logical conclusion was drawn prior to initiating the next iteration3.

 

Remediation Dimension Deficient Practice (ASM & Software Tuning Trap) Restructured Compliant Practice (TerraPulse Protocol) Statutory & Judicial Authority Satisfied
Distinguishing Uncertainty from Variability Treating natural variability in raw materials or user conditions as technical uncertainty6. Documenting why known mathematical and signal-processing models fail to decouple multi-path acoustic scattering within strict latency bounds5. ITAA 1997 s 355-25(1)(a); PKWK [2021] AATA 706; Coal of Queensland [2021]19.
Overcoming the Optimisation Trap Iterative hyperparameter tuning and sensor re-alignment via trial and error6. Formulating an ex-ante physics-informed neural network hypothesis and isolating single algorithmic variables against calibrated reference standards6. ITAA 1997 s 355-25(1)(a) & (b); Active Sports Management [2024] FCA 134610.
Contemporaneous Substantiation Relying on generic Jira tickets, Slack/WeChat logs, and year-end consultant interviews5. Automated MLOps experiment tracking tied to Hypothesis IDs, baseline literature reviews, and fortnightly R&D Review Board minutes5. Rix’s Creek [2017] AATA 645; Active Sports Management [2023] AATA 40785.
Supporting Activity & Commercial Separation Testing on a live commercial production line under a standard client supply contract5. Dedicated off-line experimental bypass loop governed by an at-risk R&D bailment agreement and separated cost centres5. ITAA 1997 s 355-25(2), s 355-30(2) & s 355-210; ATO Taxpayer Alert TA 2023/416.

5. Strategic Synthesis for Australian Tax Practitioners and R&D Entities

The trajectory of Active Sports Management Pty Ltd and Industry Innovation and Science Australia—from administrative disallowance by IISA, to complete defeat before the AAT in [2023] AATA 4078, and final dismissal with costs by the Federal Court of Australia in [2024] FCA 1346—crystallises a non-negotiable compliance paradigm for Australian corporations and their tax advisors3. Both regulators (DISR/IISA and the ATO) and the judiciary strictly enforce the text and policy intent of Division 355 of the ITAA 199714. Innovation, commercial novelty, bespoke customisation, and arduous engineering prototyping do not entitle a taxpayer to the R&D tax offset unless those endeavours are embedded within a demonstrably scientific, hypothesis-driven experimental framework aimed at resolving objective technical uncertainty that a competent professional cannot determine in advance6. Above all, the decision proves that in Australia’s self-assessment RDTI system, substantive technical eligibility and contemporaneous documentary architecture are legally inseparable: an entity that cannot prove its ex-ante hypotheses and variable-isolated experiments through rigorous, contemporaneous written records will fail to discharge its statutory onus of proof5.

Posted on Google Google
Daniel McGregor  profile picture
Daniel McGregor
11. August, 2022
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I have been using Swanson Reed for my clients for more than a decade. Having a specialist firm that can provide practical and commercial advice that produces real outcomes is very important and we have received great feedback from our clients. Highly recommended.
Posted on Google Google
John  profile picture
John
15. June, 2022
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Damian and the rest of the team at Swanson Reed have been supporting us for several years. We always appreciate their insights, expertise, and efforts.
Posted on Google Google
Rueben Rajasingam  profile picture
Rueben Rajasingam
6. June, 2022
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Experienced responsive Team. They have been a great help to me and my company navigate the R&D tax claim process and have provided invaluable advice.
Posted on Google Google
Enrique Esquivel  profile picture
Enrique Esquivel
6. June, 2022
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Damian and the team at Swanson Reed have been extremely helpfully and professional during all of our consultations. Highly recommended.
Posted on Google Google
Jess at Y&C  profile picture
Jess at Y&C
3. June, 2022
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Posted on Google Google
Anatole Kononewsky  profile picture
Anatole Kononewsky
2. June, 2022
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
The Swanson Reed team have provided our company with exceptional professional advice and assistance for all of our R&D claims for many years - have always achieved great results with excellent value for their services.
Posted on Google Google
Payam Toloo  profile picture
Payam Toloo
2. June, 2022
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Damian Smyth and his team are very helpful, supportive and experts in their field of R&D Tax claims. I'm always happy with the work they do and been a customer of their for over 5 years.
Posted on Google Google
Melissa Doddy  profile picture
Melissa Doddy
31. May, 2022
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
The Team at Swanson Reed are very experienced R&D Tax Advisors and gave us ongoing support with all of our R&D Claims, the consultants ensured we were always working with current legislative guidelines, gave us assistance with compiling technical and government documentation and went out their way to ensure they were with us for the entire process from beginning to end. Highly recommended to anyone who needs assistance with working through what can at times be a daunting process.
Posted on Google Google
Gary Watson  profile picture
Gary Watson
31. May, 2022
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
We can highly recommend Swanson and Reed as an R & D accountant. We have worked with them for several years now as they make our R & D claim so easy and communicate quickly with both us and our accountant.
Posted on Google Google
Rob van den Bergh  profile picture
Rob van den Bergh
31. May, 2022
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Always professional.