Legal and Technical Analysis of Havilah Resources Ltd and Innovation and Science Australia [2020] AATA 933: Statutory Interpretation, Evidentiary Thresholds, and Remedial Governance under Division 355 of the ITAA 1997

1. Executive Summary & Case Background

The decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal or AAT) in Havilah Resources Ltd and Innovation and Science Australia (Taxation) [2020] AATA 933 (reported at (2020) 170 ALD 374), handed down on 16 April 2020 by Deputy President P Britten-Jones, represents a watershed moment in the administration of Australia’s Research and Development (R&D) Tax Incentive1. Following closely on the heels of the Full Federal Court’s landmark ruling in Moreton Resources Ltd v Innovation and Science Australia [2019] FCAFC 120 and the Tribunal’s decision in Coal of Queensland Pty Ltd and Innovation and Science Australia [2020] AATA 126, the Havilah Resources ruling clarifies the strict statutory boundaries separating eligible scientific experimentation from routine mineral exploration, geotechnical site characterisation, and regulatory compliance activities within the Australian resources sector1.

The Taxpayer’s Claim and Disputed Activities

The applicant, Havilah Resources Ltd (Havilah), is a South Australian mineral exploration and development company controlling multiple mining tenements holding iron ore, gold, and copper deposits across north-eastern South Australia1. Havilah registered a suite of R&D activities under the R&D Tax Incentive scheme across the 2012–13 (FY13) and 2013–14 (FY14) income years1. The registrations centred on three primary tenement project areas—Maldorky (an iron ore deposit), Portia (a gold resource of about 67,000 ounces situated approximately 70 metres into the bedrock), and Kalkaroo (a copper-gold deposit)—and encompassed six specific purported “core R&D activities”1. At the Maldorky project, Havilah claimed two core activities: understanding the hydrology of the Maldorky region and developing a process for groundwater management, alongside securing fine-grained Maldorky tailings resulting from ore beneficiation1. At the Portia project and surrounding tenements, Havilah registered three core activities: investigating the hydrogeology of the Portia area basement rock aquifer system, investigating the hydrogeology of regional palaeochannel aquifer systems, and developing a cost-effective design for confining fine-grained Portia tailings1. Finally, at the Kalkaroo project, Havilah registered a sixth core activity comprising the investigation of gold in tertiary clays at Kalkaroo1. Alongside these six registered core activities, Havilah also sought to claim associated “supporting R&D activities” conducted during the FY13 and FY14 income years1.

The Regulatory Challenge and Procedural History

Australia’s R&D Tax Incentive operates under a bifurcated, dual-agency administrative model in which Innovation and Science Australia (ISA—subsequently renamed Industry Innovation and Science Australia, assisted by AusIndustry) administers the registration and technical eligibility of R&D activities under the Industry Research and Development Act 1986 (Cth) (the IR&D Act), while the Commissioner of Taxation (via the Australian Taxation Office, or ATO) administers the expenditure rules and tax offset assessments under Division 355 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth) (ITAA 1997)1.

Following a compliance examination of Havilah’s FY13 and FY14 registrations, ISA (referred to under the IR&D Act as ‘the Board’) made a formal post-registration finding on 22 December 2015 pursuant to section 27J of the IR&D Act, following a formal examination under section 27F, determining that certain of the claimed activities were not eligible “core R&D activities” or “supporting R&D activities”1. Havilah requested an internal review of the section 27J finding; however, on 23 November 2016, a delegate of ISA confirmed that finding on internal review under section 30D of the IR&D Act1. On 19 December 2016, Havilah applied to the Taxation and Commercial Division of the AAT pursuant to section 30E of the IR&D Act for an independent merits review of ISA’s internal review decision1. Findings made under Part III of the IR&D Act are binding on the Commissioner of Taxation for the purposes of determining a taxpayer’s entitlement to a refundable or non-refundable R&D tax offset under Division 355 of the ITAA 19971.

The Governing Statutory Framework

The substantive legal dispute before the Tribunal turned on the construction and application of Division 355 of the ITAA 1997 as it stood during the FY13 and FY14 income years1. Under section 355-20 of the ITAA 1997, “R&D activities” are defined exhaustively as either “core R&D activities” or “supporting R&D activities”7. Section 355-25(1) of the ITAA 1997 establishes a cumulative two-limb positive test for “core R&D activities”1. Under the first limb—the uncertainty and scientific method requirement in section 355-25(1)(a)—core R&D activities must be experimental activities whose outcome cannot be known or determined in advance on the basis of current knowledge, information or experience, but can only be determined by applying a systematic progression of work that is based on principles of established science and proceeds from hypothesis to experiment, observation and evaluation, and leads to logical conclusions4. Under the second limb—the purposive requirement in section 355-25(1)(b)—those experimental activities must be conducted for the purpose of generating new knowledge, including new knowledge in the form of new or improved materials, products, devices, processes or services5.

Even where an activity satisfies the positive threshold of section 355-25(1), section 355-25(2) carves out specific statutory exclusions that deem certain activities not to be core R&D activities2. Two exclusions were central to the Tribunal’s analysis in Havilah Resources. First, the mineral exploration exclusion in section 355-25(2)(b) disqualifies prospecting, exploring or drilling for minerals or petroleum for the purposes of discovering deposits, determining more precisely the location of deposits, or determining the size or quality of deposits5. Second, the statutory compliance and standards exclusion in section 355-25(2)(f) disqualifies activities associated with complying with statutory requirements or standards, including maintaining national standards, calibrating secondary standards and routine testing and analysis of materials, components, products, processes, soils, atmospheres and other things2. Finally, section 355-30 of the ITAA 1997 defines “supporting R&D activities” as activities directly related to core R&D activities, subject to the requirement under section 355-30(2) that if an activity falls within a section 355-25(2) exclusion or produces goods or services, it must be undertaken for the dominant purpose of supporting core R&D activities4.

The Tribunal’s Final Holding

Deputy President Britten-Jones affirmed ISA’s internal review decision in full, holding that none of the six activities registered by Havilah for the FY13 and FY14 income years satisfied the statutory definition of “core R&D activities” under section 355-25(1) of the ITAA 19971. The Tribunal concluded, accepting the opinion of the respondent’s expert hydrogeologist Mr Hugh Middlemis, that the hydrogeological and geotechnical investigations undertaken by Havilah (and, at Kalkaroo, the sampling and testing of tertiary clays) applied standard, routine methods to resolve site-specific mining project questions rather than testing a hypothesis by experimentation; Mr Middlemis also gave evidence that adequate information was available prior to 2012 for the general outcomes to be broadly understood1. Furthermore, Havilah lacked contemporaneous documentation evidencing the formulation of scientific hypotheses or a systematic progression of work conducted in a scientific way1.

Crucially, the Tribunal also held that the majority of the claimed activities were affirmatively disqualified by the statutory exclusions in section 355-25(2)—most notably section 355-25(2)(f), because the groundwater and tailings activities were associated with complying with South Australian statutory mining lease and environmental approval requirements, and section 355-25(2)(b), because the Kalkaroo clay investigations constituted mineral exploration1. Because no valid core R&D activities existed, all claimed supporting R&D activities automatically failed ab initio without requiring separate substantive evaluation5.

2. Core Legal & Evidentiary Failures

A forensic examination of the Tribunal’s reasoning in Havilah Resources reveals seven distinct, compounding legal and evidentiary failures that proved fatal to the taxpayer’s claim. Together, these deficiencies illustrate how operational resource development workflows collapse when subjected to rigorous administrative review under Division 355 of the ITAA 1997.

 

Disputed Registered Activity Project Site & Tenement Focus Underlying Technical & Operational Work Primary Statutory Failure Grounds (ITAA 1997)
1. Understanding hydrology of the Maldorky region and developing a process for groundwater management Maldorky Iron Ore Project (South Australia)1 Pump testing of existing drillholes (carried out in July 2011, before the first registration year), groundwater sampling, and numerical groundwater modelling by Aldam Geoscience to assess baseline hydrogeology and pit dewatering rates1. s 355-25(1)(a) & (b): Standard hydrogeological methods; no scientific hypothesis; routine data gathering1.

s 355-25(2)(f): Associated with statutory mining lease / PEPR approvals1.

2. Securing fine-grained Maldorky tailings Maldorky Iron Ore Project (South Australia)1 Geotechnical testing and engineering design for tailings storage facilities (TSF) to contain fine-grained iron ore waste1. s 355-25(1)(a): Standard laboratory tests and geotechnical modelling; routine investigation rather than experimental testing of a hypothesis1.

s 355-25(2)(f): Associated with the TSF requirements of Ministerial Determination 005 (para 3.9); BTM Solutions report prepared to support a mining lease proposal1.

3. Hydrogeology of the Portia area basement rock aquifer system Portia Gold Project (South Australia)1 Pumping tests at the Portia site and numerical groundwater modelling (AGT ‘Portia Dewatering Assessment’, April 2013) to design an open-pit dewatering bore-field; in 2013/14, pumps installed in nine bores to refine the model1. s 355-25(1)(a) & (b): Routine site characterisation applying established ‘published solutions’; no hypothesis postulated or recorded in the AGT report1.

s 355-25(2)(f): Dual purpose involving statutory mine permitting compliance1.

4. Hydrogeology of regional palaeochannel aquifer systems Portia / Regional Tenements (South Australia)1 Drilling 21 bores (April–May 2013) to locate and test the Shylock Palaeochannel and modelling a managed aquifer recharge (MAR) scheme to dispose of excess mine dewatering water1. s 355-25(1)(a) & (b): Absence of documented hypothesis; standard hydrological investigation1.

s 355-25(2)(f): Undertaken to satisfy regulatory groundwater management mandates1.

5. Cost-effective design for confining fine-grained Portia tailings Portia Gold Project (South Australia)1 Field data collection, geotechnical and seepage test work and modelling (Golder Associates, June 2013) to design a TSF using local materials rather than an expensive plastic liner1. s 355-25(1)(a): Standard sampling, testing and seepage modelling of variables whose causal relationships were already well known; site-specific knowledge only1.

s 355-25(2)(f): Directly linked to Ministerial Determination 005 (para 3.9) and Mining Regulatory Guidelines MG2; Golder engaged as part of the approvals process1.

6. Investigation of gold in tertiary clays at Kalkaroo Kalkaroo Copper-Gold Project (South Australia)1 Drilling, sampling, and assaying tertiary clay horizons to identify the distribution, grade, and recoverability of fine gold1. s 355-25(1)(a) & (b): No contemporaneous hypothesis or process of experiment, observation and evaluation; routine sampling and testing yielding site-specific information for Havilah’s sole benefit1.

s 355-25(2)(b): Excluded mineral exploration (gold mineralisation in the tertiary clays found to be a ‘deposit’); the Tribunal did not apply s 355-25(2)(f) to this activity4.

1. Conflation of Site-Specific Geological Variability with Scientific or Technical Uncertainty

The foundational error pervading Havilah’s claim was the conflation of observational uncertainty regarding subsurface geological conditions with scientific or technical uncertainty under section 355-25(1)(a) of the ITAA 19971. In every mining and civil engineering project, the exact hydraulic conductivity of a fractured basement rock aquifer (Activity 3), the transmissivity and storage coefficient of a regional palaeochannel (Activity 4), the consolidation parameters of site-specific fine-grained tailings (Activities 2 and 5), or the grade distribution of gold in tertiary clays (Activity 6) are unknown prior to physical drilling, sampling, and testing1.

However, the Tribunal held that it is not enough that the outcomes could not have been known in advance: information derived from a routine investigation of site-specific conditions is not an outcome that can only be determined by applying a systematic progression of work that proceeds from hypothesis to experiment, observation and evaluation within the meaning of section 355-25(1)(a)1. The respondent’s expert, Mr Hugh Middlemis, gave evidence that adequate information was available prior to 2012 for the general outcomes of Havilah’s hydrogeological investigations to be broadly understood, and the Tribunal accepted his opinion that the investigations applied standard methods to routine questions1. Standard hydrogeological methods (pumping tests analysed using a suite of established ‘published solutions’, and groundwater models built with standard modelling software) and standard geotechnical testing (laboratory tests measuring particle size, specific gravity and permeability, and standard geotechnical seepage modelling software) were applied to perform routine site-characterisation tasks1. As the jurisprudence confirms, complexity does not equal experimentation, geological variability does not equal scientific uncertainty, and routine investigations applying established professional methodologies are not “experimental activities”1.

2. Absence of a Valid Scientific Hypothesis and Failure of the Systematic Progression Test

Under section 355-25(1)(a)(ii), an eligible experimental activity must proceed from a “hypothesis to experiment, observation and evaluation, and lead to logical conclusions”4. The Tribunal identified two fatal flaws in Havilah’s approach to hypotheses. First, the hypotheses articulated by Havilah in its registration applications (for example, that groundwater could be drawn upon without undue impact on the groundwater system, that the planned Portia open pit could be adequately dewatered, or that an innovative tailings storage facility could be designed using indigenous materials) were expressed in terms particular to each mine site, which the Tribunal characterised as statements of a proposed resolution of a routine problem at the particular site1. Consistently with the Explanatory Memorandum’s statement that an experiment entails investigating causal relationships among relevant variables to test a hypothesis or determine the efficacy of something previously untried, a desire to minimise capital expenditure on a tailings storage facility or to locate a viable water disposal aquifer, pursued through routine site characterisation, did not involve the testing of a hypothesis by experimentation1.

Second, the Tribunal observed that there was no written expression of any hypothesis until May 2014, when Havilah applied to register its activities, and that no hypothesis was referred to in the consultant reports generated as part of the claimed activities, the consultants not having been engaged to test any hypothesis by experimentation5. Rather than designing controlled experiments to isolate variables and test a specific scientific proposition to validation or falsification, Havilah conducted open-ended data collection, exploratory drilling, and iterative engineering design refinement1. In accordance with the statutory text, observational learning, data gathering, and iterative parameter adjustment to optimise a known engineering system do not constitute a systematic progression of work proceeding from a hypothesis4.

3. Fatal Deficiency in Contemporaneous Documentation and the Standard of Proof

A central pillar of Deputy President Britten-Jones’ decision is the link between the statutory requirement that work be carried out “in a scientific way” (drawn from the object clause in section 355-5(2), which informs the meaning of the ‘systematic progression of work’ required by section 355-25(1)(a)) and the necessity of contemporaneous documentation1. The Tribunal acknowledged that there is no express legislative obligation requiring the hypothesis to be expressed in writing, but reasoned that the inclusion of the words ‘in a scientific way’ in the statutory object suggests that the systematic progression of work should be recorded so as to achieve that standard, and that establishing such a progression would invariably require written evidence4.

In Havilah Resources, there were no contemporaneous R&D plans, experimental protocols, or project records documenting the formulation of a scientific hypothesis prior to the commencement of the fieldwork, nor records tracking the systematic evaluation of experimental results against that hypothesis during the FY13 and FY14 income years1. At the hearing, Havilah relied on written statements and oral evidence from three company witnesses (Dr Chris Giles, Mr Travis Just and Dr Geoffrey Stolz) and two expert witnesses (Mr John Curtis and Mr Richard Aldam, whose firm Aldam Geoscience had also prepared consultant reports for Havilah) to establish the scientific character of the activities retrospectively; Dr Giles conceded that many of the hypotheses were only ‘in our heads’11. The Tribunal held that the lack of documentation evidencing a hypothesis created a real evidentiary difficulty for Havilah, gave Mr Curtis’ opinions very little weight because he disagreed with aspects of the statutory definition, and endorsed the view in Docklands Science Park Pty Ltd and Innovation Australia [2015] AATA 973 that an applicant cannot succeed in establishing the statutory requirements in the absence of detailed documentation recording the process of each activity as it develops1.

4. Failure of the “Purpose of Generating New Knowledge” Limb

Section 355-25(1)(b) mandates that core R&D activities be conducted “for the purpose of generating new knowledge (including new knowledge in the form of new or improved materials, products, devices, processes or services)”5. The Tribunal found that the knowledge generated by Havilah’s activities was site specific, being generated from routine methods of investigation at particular sites and, as the Tribunal expressly found in relation to Kalkaroo, acquired for the sole benefit of Havilah and its shareholders rather than for the purpose of generating new knowledge likely to benefit the wider Australian economy1.

Acquiring empirical data about the physical properties of a specific orebody, overburden clay layer, or local aquifer—even if that specific spatial data was previously unrecorded—does not constitute generating “new knowledge” within the contemplation of Division 355 where that data is merely obtained via standard diagnostic techniques to populate conventional geological or hydrological models1. The Tribunal construed ‘new knowledge’ in light of the statutory object that the knowledge gained is likely to benefit the wider Australian economy, and as a feature of experimental activities conducted in a scientific way, noting that it is not merely the generation of new knowledge that gives rise to the entitlement; at the same time, following Moreton Resources, new knowledge concerning the application of an existing technology at a new site is capable of qualifying depending on the circumstances1.

5. The “Dual Purpose” Trap and the Broad Scope of the Statutory Compliance Exclusion

Perhaps the most doctrinally significant aspect of Havilah Resources is the Tribunal’s rigorous construction of the statutory compliance exclusion in section 355-25(2)(f) of the ITAA 19972. Under South Australian mining legislation, a tenement holder cannot progress from an exploration licence to a production mining lease or commence mining operations without submitting comprehensive hydrogeological, groundwater management, and tailings storage facility designs as part of a Mining Lease Proposal and a Program for Environment Protection and Rehabilitation (PEPR), with the minimum information for a PEPR (including mine dewatering, process water management and tailings storage facilities) prescribed by Ministerial Determination 005, gazetted on 12 July 2012 under regulation 65(7) of the Mining Regulations 2011 (SA) and given statutory force by section 70B of the Mining Act 1971 (SA)1.

Havilah’s evidence, through Dr Giles, was that it worked on feasibility studies (to determine how to dewater the pits safely and confine fine-grained tailings cost-effectively) and on permitting activities ‘in parallel’1. The Tribunal held that even if the claimed activities were carried out for such a dual purpose the exclusion would be engaged, applying a strict “dual purpose” rule under section 355-25(2)(f)4. The statutory language of section 355-25(2)(f) excludes activities “associated with complying with statutory requirements or standards”2. Unlike section 355-30(2), which governs supporting R&D activities and explicitly utilises a “dominant purpose” test, section 355-25(2)(f) contains no qualifier limiting its operation to activities conducted for the sole or dominant purpose of statutory compliance4. Consequently, the Tribunal held that the statutory compliance exclusion is broad and applies to all activities associated with regulatory or standards compliance4. Where a dual purpose exists—such as advancing technical mine design while simultaneously generating data and designs required to satisfy statutory mining lease or PEPR conditions—and one of those purposes is excluded under section 355-25(2)(f), the activity is fatally tainted and incapable of amounting to a core R&D activity4.

6. The Mineral Exploration Exclusion and External Consultant Scoping Deficiencies

With respect to Activity 6 (Investigation of gold in tertiary clays at Kalkaroo), the Tribunal applied the mineral exploration exclusion in section 355-25(2)(b), without applying the statutory compliance exclusion in section 355-25(2)(f) to that activity4. Section 355-25(2)(b) explicitly excludes prospecting, exploring, or drilling for minerals for the purposes of discovering deposits, determining more precisely the location of deposits, or determining the size or quality of deposits5. The Tribunal found that the ‘significant gold mineralisation’ in the tertiary clays fell within the Geoscience Australia definition of a mineral deposit (accepted by Dr Giles in cross-examination), and that Havilah was exploring and drilling for gold in the tertiary clays for the purpose of determining more precisely the location, size and quality of that deposit; Havilah’s additional purpose of testing whether gold in the clays indicated primary bedrock mineralisation did not preclude that excluded purpose, and the fact that the deposit proved uneconomic was irrelevant because it is the purpose, not the outcome, of the exploration that matters1.

Furthermore, the evidentiary record at Maldorky and Portia was undermined by how Havilah engaged external hydrogeological and geotechnical consultants (Aldam Geoscience, Australian Groundwater Technologies, BTM Solutions and Golder Associates), while at Kalkaroo there were no contemporaneous consultant reports at all. Rather than contracting external specialists under bespoke R&D statements of work requiring hypothesis-driven experimental testing, the consultants were engaged under standard commercial engineering scopes to deliver feasibility-level hydrogeological assessments, TSF design reports, and regulatory compliance documentation for inclusion in statutory mining lease applications1. The deliverables produced by these contractors served as direct documentary evidence against Havilah, proving to the Tribunal that the work consisted of standard engineering and statutory compliance tasks rather than core R&D1.

7. Automatic Collapse of Supporting R&D Activities

Finally, the Tribunal addressed the status of Havilah’s claimed supporting R&D activities under sections 355-20 and 355-30 of the ITAA 19977. By statutory definition, a supporting R&D activity must be “directly related to core R&D activities” (or, where caught by section 355-30(2), undertaken for the dominant purpose of supporting core R&D activities)4. Because the Tribunal held that none of the six registered core activities met the threshold of section 355-25(1) (and were further excluded by section 355-25(2)), there were no valid core R&D activities in existence1. As the Tribunal succinctly concluded, where there are no core R&D activities, there can be no supporting R&D activities, rendering any further inquiry into section 355-30 otiose5.

3. Comparative Summary Table

The following table maps each statutory requirement examined in Havilah Resources Ltd and Innovation and Science Australia [2020] AATA 933 against the specific deficiencies in the taxpayer’s claim and the legal and evidentiary standard of proof established by the Tribunal.

 

Statutory Provision & Legal Requirement (ITAA 1997 / IR&D Act 1986) Taxpayer’s Legal, Technical & Evidentiary Failure in Havilah Resources Tribunal’s Standard of Proof & Doctrinal Benchmark
s 355-25(1) (Chapeau):

Activities must be “experimental activities”7.

Characterised routine hydrogeological pump tests, piezometer monitoring, geotechnical soil/tailings testing, and clay gold assays as “experimental” merely because physical site parameters were previously unmeasured1. Routine investigations are not experimental activities7. Following Moreton Resources, the words ‘experimental activities’ do little work beyond paragraphs (a) and (b); the Explanatory Memorandum describes an experiment as investigating causal relationships among relevant variables to test a hypothesis or determine the efficacy of something previously untried, which is not satisfied by merely applying standard methods to obtain site-specific data1.
s 355-25(1)(a) (First Limb):

Outcome cannot be known or determined in advance on the basis of current knowledge, information or experience1.

Asserted technical uncertainty where the only uncertainty was observational or commercial (i.e., exact aquifer yield, permeability of basement rock, or cost of TSF construction)1. Unknowability of the outcome is necessary but not sufficient: the Tribunal held that it is not enough that the outcomes could not have been known in advance, because the outcome must be one that can only be determined by a systematic progression of work proceeding from hypothesis. The respondent’s expert evidence, which the Tribunal accepted, was that standard methods were applied and that adequate information existed prior to 2012 for the general outcomes to be broadly understood1.
s 355-25(1)(a)(i) & (ii):

Systematic progression of work based on principles of established science, proceeding from hypothesis to experiment, observation, evaluation, and logical conclusions1.

Framed broad commercial or operational goals (e.g., “developing a process for groundwater management”, “cost-effective design for confining tailings”) as hypotheses; failed to document any hypothesis prior to work commencing; hypotheses were first written down in the May 2014 registration application and were not referred to in any consultant report1. The hypothesis must drive a systematic progression of work proceeding from hypothesis to experiment, observation and evaluation; hypotheses framed as a proposed resolution of a routine problem at a particular site do not suffice. Although there is no express legislative obligation to record the hypothesis in writing, conducting work ‘in a scientific way’ suggests the systematic progression should be recorded, and establishing it would invariably require written evidence4.
s 355-25(1)(b):

Conducted for the purpose of generating new knowledge (including new or improved materials, products, devices, processes or services)5.

Conducted activities to gather site-specific baseline data, delineate deposit characteristics, and refine known mine/tailings engineering designs for internal project feasibility and permitting1. Site-specific knowledge generated by routine investigations for the sole benefit of the taxpayer is not the requisite new knowledge, which is construed in light of the object that the knowledge gained is likely to benefit the wider Australian economy. The purpose of generating new knowledge need not be dominant but must be substantial (JLSP and Innovation Australia [2016] AATA 23), and can extend to the application of an existing technology at a new site (Moreton Resources)1.
s 355-25(2)(f):

Exclusion for activities associated with complying with statutory requirements or standards, or routine testing and analysis of materials/soils2.

Claimed groundwater management and tailings confinement studies at Maldorky and Portia that were simultaneously required to obtain South Australian Mining Leases, PEPR environmental approvals, and address the dewatering, groundwater and TSF requirements of Ministerial Determination 0051. Strict “Dual Purpose” Disqualification: Section 355-25(2)(f) is broad and is not limited to activities conducted for the sole or dominant purpose of compliance4. Where a dual purpose exists and one purpose is associated with statutory or standards compliance, the activity is wholly excluded from being a core R&D activity7.
s 355-25(2)(b):

Exclusion for prospecting, exploring or drilling for minerals to discover deposits or determine location, size, or quality5.

Registered the investigation of gold in tertiary clays at Kalkaroo and exploratory drilling programmes aimed at evaluating the presence, grade, and distribution of mineralisation1. Any drilling, sampling, or assaying activity directed at ascertaining the location, spatial extent, grade, or metallurgical quality of a mineral resource is statutorily excluded as generic exploration under s 355-25(2)(b)5.
s 355-20 & s 355-30:

Eligibility of supporting R&D activities4.

Attempted to maintain claims for supporting R&D activities notwithstanding the disqualification of all six registered core R&D activities4. Absolute Derivative Dependency: Supporting R&D activities cannot exist in a vacuum7. If the taxpayer fails to establish at least one valid core R&D activity under s 355-25, all associated supporting R&D activities under s 355-30 automatically fail without further consideration5.
s 30E IR&D Act 1986 & Evidentiary Burden:

Substantiation of registration criteria before the AAT1.

Relied on retrospective written and oral evidence from three company witnesses (Dr Giles, Mr Just and Dr Stolz) and two experts (Mr Curtis and Mr Aldam) in the absence of contemporaneous R&D documentation1. While the AAT conducts a merits review, the practical onus rests on the applicant to provide contemporaneous, objective documentary evidence proving each statutory element of s 355-251. The lack of documentation created a real evidentiary difficulty; following Docklands Science Park, an applicant cannot succeed in the absence of detailed documentation recording the process of each activity as it develops1.

Doctrinal Synthesis: Reconciling Moreton Resources, Coal of Queensland, and Havilah Resources

From a senior tax advisory perspective, Havilah Resources must be read in tandem with the Full Federal Court’s decision in Moreton Resources Ltd v Innovation and Science Australia [2019] FCAFC 120 and the Tribunal’s contemporaneous decision in Coal of Queensland Pty Ltd and Innovation and Science Australia [2020] AATA 1264. In Moreton Resources, the Full Federal Court overturned an overly restrictive AAT ruling, holding that the words “experimental activities” in the chapeau of section 355-25(1) perform work largely by reference to paragraphs (a) and (b), and that activities having the purpose of generating new knowledge with respect to the application of an existing technology (underground coal gasification) at a new site are capable, depending on the circumstances, of qualifying if paragraphs (a) and (b) are satisfied4.

However, many resource sector taxpayers mistakenly interpreted Moreton Resources as a carte blanche to claim site-specific geological, hydrogeological, and metallurgical investigations. Coal of Queensland and Havilah Resources decisively closed that door4. First, whereas Moreton Resources concerned activities directed at generating new knowledge about the application of an existing technology (underground coal gasification) at a new site, Havilah Resources involved standard and routine hydrogeological drilling, sampling and pumping tests, routine groundwater modelling and standard geotechnical laboratory tests, the tools and principles of which, as Havilah’s own expert Mr Aldam accepted, were common and long established1. Second, Havilah Resources applies (drawing on the Tribunal’s observation in Moreton Resources Ltd and Innovation and Science Australia [2018] AATA 3378 at [211] that the words ‘associated with’ suggest a broad operation) a formidable hurdle via its “dual purpose” interpretation of section 355-25(2)(f)4. Even if an activity appears to satisfy the broad reading of “experimental activities” under Moreton Resources, if that activity is simultaneously undertaken to generate data or designs associated with statutory mining lease, environmental (PEPR), or engineering standards compliance, section 355-25(2)(f) operates as an absolute bar to core R&D eligibility4. At most, an activity excluded by section 355-25(2)(f) can only ever be claimed as a supporting R&D activity under section 355-30(2)—and even then, only if the taxpayer can prove both that a separate, unexcluded core R&D activity exists, and that the excluded activity was undertaken for the dominant purpose of supporting that core R&D activity4.

4. Two Applied Remedial Case Studies

To demonstrate how Australian taxpayers and R&D tax advisors can proactively structure complex technical projects to overcome the exact legal, contractual, and evidentiary pitfalls identified in Havilah Resources [2020] AATA 933, two applied industry case studies are presented below.

Comparative Remedial Blueprint: Pre-Restructure vs. Post-Restructure

 

Governance & Evidentiary Dimension Pre-Restructure: Disqualified Havilah Resources Approach Post-Restructure: Compliant Division 355 Architecture
Activity Scoping & Statutory Exclusions (s 355-25(2)(b) & (f)) Bundles whole-of-mine hydrogeological studies, TSF engineering designs, and resource drilling into broad “core R&D” registrations that overlap with statutory PEPR/Mining Lease approvals and JORC resource definition1. Strict Structural Ring-Fencing: Carves out all routine drilling, JORC assaying, and statutory PEPR/ANCOLD compliance work into non-R&D (or s 355-30(2) supporting) cost centres. Isolates only discrete, non-compliance laboratory/pilot experiments as Core R&D4.
Hypothesis Formulation (s 355-25(1)(a)(ii)) States commercial or operational goals (e.g., “develop a cost-effective tailings design” or “understand regional aquifer hydrology”)1. Formulates falsifiable scientific hypotheses specifying independent/dependent variables, physical-chemical mechanisms, and quantifiable falsification thresholds grounded in established scientific principles4.
Establishing Uncertainty & Prior Knowledge (s 355-25(1)(a)) Relies on the fact that site-specific permeability, water table depth, or clay gold grade is unknown prior to drilling1. Conducts and documents a formal Pre-Project Literature & Patent Review proving why established pre-existing scientific/engineering models fail or yield contradictory predictions due to specific anomalous physicochemical mechanisms1.
Contemporaneous Documentation (“In a Scientific Way”) Relies on standard exploration logs, statutory feasibility reports, and retrospective witness statements prepared years later for AAT litigation1. Implements Stage-Gate R&D Governance Logs: Board-approved Ex Ante R&D Plans, Hypothesis Registers, Controlled Experimental Protocols, Variable Isolation Logs, and Failure/Iteration Evaluations recorded contemporaneously4.
External Contractor & Consultant Contracts Engages hydrogeologists, geotechnical engineers, and labs via standard commercial purchase orders to produce feasibility and regulatory approval reports1. Executes Bespoke R&D Statements of Work (SOWs) separating routine compliance deliverables from experimental tasks; mandates hypothesis-testing protocols, raw experimental data handovers, and IP vesting in the taxpayer1.

Case Study 1: Metalliferous Mining & Tailings Geomechanics (Overcoming the s 355-25(2)(f) Dual-Purpose Statutory Compliance Exclusion and Site-Characterisation Pitfall)

Fact Pattern & The Havilah Pitfall

Flinders Iron & Gold Pty Ltd (Flinders), a South Australian resource developer, is advancing an iron-gold deposit overlain by a hyper-saline tertiary palaeochannel aquifer. Beneficiation of the ore produces ultrafine, smectite-clay-rich tailings that exhibit extreme thixotropic (gel-forming) behaviour and refuse to consolidate under gravity in conventional Tailings Storage Facilities (TSFs). Simultaneously, Flinders must dewater the open pit by reinjecting hyper-saline groundwater into the regional palaeochannel aquifer without causing formation clogging via mineral precipitation. Under the Mining Act 1971 (SA), Flinders must submit a Mining Lease Proposal and a Program for Environment Protection and Rehabilitation (PEPR) demonstrating safe TSF confinement (complying with ANCOLD guidelines) and sustainable groundwater management1.

If Flinders registers “Understanding regional palaeochannel hydrogeology for groundwater management” and “Cost-effective design for confining fine-grained tailings” as core R&D activities—and uses its consultant hydrogeological and TSF feasibility reports as substantiation—its claim will be wholly disqualified under Havilah Resources [2020] AATA 9331. First, routine aquifer pump testing and standard geotechnical consolidation testing are not experimental activities under section 355-25(1)(a)1. Second, because the hydrogeological modelling and TSF engineering designs serve a dual purpose (solving technical mine problems and satisfying statutory Mining Lease/PEPR and ANCOLD standards), they are completely excluded from being core R&D activities under section 355-25(2)(f)4.

Step-by-Step Remedial Restructuring Blueprint

Step 1: Project Governance & Structural Ring-Fencing (Defeating the s 355-25(2)(f) Dual-Purpose Trap)

To prevent the section 355-25(2)(f) statutory compliance exclusion from infecting the core R&D claim, Flinders’ tax and technical advisors must legally, operationally, and financially bifurcate the project into three distinct workstreams via a formal Board Resolution prior to commencing work4. The first workstream (Workstream A: Excluded Statutory Compliance and Routine Engineering) encompasses all baseline bore drilling, regional piezometer monitoring, standard aquifer pump tests, regional MODFLOW groundwater modelling, and ANCOLD-compliant TSF embankment stability designs required for the South Australian Mining Lease Proposal and PEPR submission1. Flinders explicitly excludes Workstream A from its R&D registration so that no statutory compliance taint attaches to the claim4.

The second workstream (Workstream B: Ring-Fenced Core R&D Activities) isolates two discrete, non-regulatory experimental research projects conducted solely to resolve fundamental physicochemical uncertainties that cannot be answered by standard geotechnical or hydrogeological engineering1. Core Activity 1 focuses on electrokinetic and polymeric synergistic flocculation of smectite tailings, utilizing bench-scale and 5-tonne pilot-column experimentation to test a novel dual-electrolyte polymeric bridging mechanism designed to disrupt smectite electrical double-layer repulsion in hyper-saline process water ( TDS). Core Activity 2 focuses on geochemical kinetic inhibition of gypsum and halite precipitation during hyper-saline aquifer reinjection, utilizing pressurised core-flooding laboratory experiments to test pulsed weak-acid and chelating-agent dosing regimes that prevent barite and gypsum crystal nucleation within low-permeability palaeochannel glauconitic sands under anoxic conditions.

The third workstream (Workstream C: Supporting R&D Activities under section 355-30) covers the extraction of specific 200-kilogram bulk smectite tailings samples and intact glauconitic sand drill cores required exclusively to feed the bench-scale and pilot-column test rigs in Workstream B4. Because physical sampling and routine baseline characterisation of soils and materials fall within section 355-25(2)(f), Flinders documents contemporaneously in its project charter that these specific sampling runs are not used for JORC resource estimation or PEPR regulatory reporting, thereby satisfying the strict “dominant purpose” test under section 355-30(2)4.

Step 2: Technical Documentation & Contemporaneous Scientific Method Architecture

Before a single experiment is conducted in Workstream B, Flinders’ R&D Steering Committee must generate and date-stamp a formal Contemporaneous R&D Experimental Plan that satisfies the Tribunal’s evidentiary benchmark4. This dossier begins with a comprehensive Pre-Project Literature Review and Knowledge Gap Analysis addressing section 355-25(1)(a), citing peer-reviewed colloid chemistry and hydrogeochemistry literature to demonstrate that existing anionic polyacrylamide flocculants undergo polymer coil collapse (salting-out) at ionic strengths exceeding , and that standard geochemical equilibrium models fail to predict kinetic surface nucleation rates in glauconitic clay matrices at high pore-fluid velocities1. This objective evidence proves that a competent professional could not know or determine the outcome in advance based on pre-existing knowledge1.

Next, the R&D Plan replaces vague commercial objectives like “cost-effective tailings confinement” with falsifiable scientific hypotheses under section 355-25(1)(a)(ii)1. For Core Activity 1, Flinders records the specific proposition that grafting sulfonate functional groups onto a high-molecular-weight non-ionic polyethylene oxide backbone at a molar ratio between and , combined with a low-voltage pulsed direct current electric field (), will prevent steric polymer coil collapse in hyper-saline tailings ( TDS) and overcome smectite edge-face card-house gelation, achieving a settled solids density of and hydraulic conductivity 4. To prove the work was carried out “in a scientific way,” Flinders maintains a cloud-based Electronic Laboratory Notebook (ELN) with immutable timestamps recording each experimental run, the independent variables manipulated (sulfonate grafting ratio, dosing concentration in , electric field voltage gradient, and shear mixing rate), the dependent variables measured (zeta potential, settling velocity, and cake moisture content), and formal technical evaluations explaining why failed trials falsified initial assumptions and necessitated hypothesis modification5.

Step 3: Contractual Terms & Consultant Engagement Restructuring

To avoid the evidentiary trap in Havilah Resources where external consultant reports resembled routine feasibility and permitting deliverables1, Flinders restructures its external procurement by executing two completely separate legal agreements. Contract 1 is executed with an environmental engineering firm for the statutory PEPR hydrogeological and TSF design reports, which are coded entirely to non-R&D capital or operational expenditure1. Simultaneously, Flinders executes a separate Master R&D Services Agreement (Contract 2) with a specialised metallurgical research institute exclusively for Workstream B. Contract 2 explicitly recites the section 355-25(1)(a) scientific hypotheses in its Statement of Work, prohibits the research contractor from performing routine Australian Standard (AS 1289) soil classification tests under that scope, and mandates the delivery of raw experimental trial datasets and failure analyses rather than a commercial feasibility study chapter1. Furthermore, Contract 2 includes an express negative covenant warranting that none of the experimental activities or deliverables commissioned under the Statement of Work are designed for, or capable of being used directly to satisfy, any statutory permitting, PEPR, or ANCOLD compliance requirement4. Finally, the contract stipulates that all foreground intellectual property (new knowledge in the form of the novel dewatering and reinjection processes) vests ab initio in Flinders, and structures remuneration on a time-and-materials basis without technical performance guarantees, satisfying the Division 355 “for whom” and “at-risk” expenditure rules5.

Step 4: Experimentation Tracking, Variable Isolation & Financial Apportionment

To substantiate the claim before both AusIndustry and the ATO, Flinders implements a granular Work Breakdown Structure (WBS) within its enterprise resource planning (ERP) system4. The company establishes segregated general ledger cost centres (RND-CORE-01, RND-CORE-02, RND-SUPP-01, and NON-RND-PEPR) and requires all internal metallurgists, hydrogeologists, and project engineers to complete contemporaneous weekly timesheets allocating hours strictly to specific experimental protocol IDs rather than generic tenement codes4. Depreciation and capital allowances for shared laboratory or pilot-plant assets are apportioned strictly on the basis of logged experimental operating hours versus routine diagnostic hours, ensuring full compliance with Division 355 expenditure nexus requirements4.

Case Study 2: Refractory Ore Hydrometallurgy & Clay-Hosted Mineral Beneficiation (Overcoming the s 355-25(2)(b) Exploration Exclusion, Retrospective Hypothesis Failure, and Consultant Scoping Deficiencies)

Fact Pattern & The Havilah Pitfall

Curnamona Critical Minerals Ltd (Curnamona) holds an exploration tenement in Australia containing a deep copper-gold sulphide deposit capped by a 60-metre-thick blanket of tertiary saprolitic and montmorillonite clays. Historical drilling indicates that significant fine gold and ionic rare earth elements (REEs) are adsorbed onto the clay mineral surfaces or encapsulated within sub-micron iron-oxide (goethite) coatings. Curnamona conducts a 50-hole air-core drilling campaign across the tertiary clay horizon, sends 2,000 clay samples to a commercial assay laboratory for fire assay and standard cyanide bottle-roll leach tests, and engages a metallurgical consultant to determine where the recoverable gold is located and whether the clay horizon can be economically processed.

If Curnamona registers “Investigation of gold and rare earths in tertiary clays” as a core R&D activity—mirroring Havilah’s Activity 6 (“Investigation of gold in tertiary clays at Kalkaroo”)1—the claim will be summarily disallowed by IISA and the AAT. First, drilling and assaying to determine the spatial distribution, grade, size, or metallurgical quality of a mineral deposit is statutorily excluded from being a core R&D activity by section 355-25(2)(b)5. Second, standard fire assays and conventional cyanide bottle-roll tests constitute “routine testing and analysis of materials… [and] soils” excluded under section 355-25(2)(f)2. Third, as in Havilah, exploration and ore-characterisation activities using routine sampling and testing generate only site-specific information for the taxpayer’s own benefit rather than the new knowledge contemplated by section 355-25(1)(b)1.

Step-by-Step Remedial Restructuring Blueprint

Step 1: Project Governance & Structural Ring-Fencing (Neutralising the s 355-25(2)(b) Exploration Exclusion)

To survive scrutiny under Havilah Resources and Coal of Queensland5, Curnamona must establish a hard chronological and operational stage-gate boundary between Mineral Exploration/Resource Definition (excluded under section 355-25(2)(b)) and Hydrometallurgical Process R&D (eligible under section 355-25(1)). During Stage Gate 1 (Excluded Exploration and Resource Delineation), all 50 air-core drill holes, geological logging, mineralogical QEMSCAN mapping, fire assays, and standard diagnostic cyanide bottle-roll tests used to determine the location, tonnage, grade, and JORC classification of the tertiary clay deposit are classified as 100% excluded exploration5. Curnamona does not register or claim any Stage Gate 1 activities as core R&D.

The transition to Stage Gate 2 (Core R&D Commencement) is triggered only after Stage Gate 1 diagnostic results reveal a fundamental metallurgical anomaly: standard alkaline cyanidation recovers less than of the clay-hosted gold due to preg-robbing by active montmorillonite interlayers and passivation by nano-crystalline goethite rims, while conventional ammonium sulfate ion-exchange leaching causes severe clay swelling that blinds filtration circuits. At this juncture, Curnamona’s Board formally closes the resource-characterisation phase for a homogenised 500-kilogram master composite sample and authorises a dedicated Hydrometallurgical Process R&D Project4. Curnamona defines its ring-fenced Core R&D Activity strictly as the experimental development of a simultaneous reductive-organic lixiviant and divalent-cation clay-inhibition leaching process to liberate goethite-encapsulated sub-micron gold and desorb ion-adsorbed REEs without inducing montmorillonite interlayer osmotic swelling10. Because the homogenised 500-kilogram master composite has already been fully assayed for grade and quality prior to Stage Gate 2, subsequent experimental leaching trials on splits of this composite are conducted solely for the purpose of generating new process knowledge under section 355-25(1)(b), and have no utility for determining the location, size, or quality of the mineral deposit under section 355-25(2)(b)5.

Step 2: Technical Documentation & Contemporaneous Scientific Method Architecture

To eliminate the Havilah failure where no hypothesis was written down until the May 2014 registration application and none appeared in any contemporaneous record1, Curnamona institutes a strict three-tier contemporaneous documentation protocol. Under Tier 1 (Pre-Experimentation Hypothesis Dossier), prior to running any Stage Gate 2 leach tests, the Chief Metallurgist documents the exact scientific uncertainty and formulates a series of linked, falsifiable hypotheses1. Specifically, grounded in coordination chemistry and DLVO clay double-layer theory, Curnamona hypothesises that introducing a synergistic lixiviant system comprising thiosulfate catalysed by copper(II)-ethylenediamine complexes, buffered with magnesium chloride () as a divalent interlayer exchange cation at and Eh , will simultaneously compress the montmorillonite basal d-spacing below to prevent preg-robbing and viscosity surge, and reductively dissolve goethite rims to increase gold extraction from to within a 6-hour residence time4.

Under Tier 2 (Design of Experiments Matrix and Control Benchmarks), rather than conducting ad hoc trial-and-error testing, the experimental plan specifies a statistically structured Full-Factorial Design of Experiments (DoE) matrix10. Every experimental batch includes a baseline control run alongside systematic manipulation of isolated independent variables (complexing ligand concentration, divalent cation ratio , redox potential Eh, temperature, and pulp density), ensuring that variable isolation is contemporaneously demonstrable4. Under Tier 3 (Iterative Evaluation and Logical Conclusion Reports), at the conclusion of each 20-test DoE block, the metallurgical team compiles a contemporaneous Hypothesis Evaluation Memo comparing observed extraction kinetics and X-ray diffraction (XRD) basal spacing measurements against the predicted hypothesis4. Where a hypothesis is falsified—for instance, if copper-ethylenediamine complexes preferentially adsorb onto clay surfaces at —the memo records the logical scientific conclusion and formulates the revised hypothesis for the next experimental iteration4.

Step 3: Contractual Terms & Consultant Engagement Restructuring

When engaging an external metallurgical testing facility to execute the bench-scale and continuous mini-pilot leach trials, Curnamona avoids generic “Metallurgical Testwork Proposals” framed around Pre-Feasibility Study (PFS) flowsheet validation1. Instead, Curnamona instructs the laboratory to issue two separate quotes and project numbers: Project Quote A for routine comminution index testing, head assays, and JORC metallurgical recovery sign-offs (which are excluded from the R&D claim); and Project Quote B exclusively for the Stage Gate 2 experimental DoE leaching matrices4. Curnamona incorporates the Tier 1 Hypothesis Dossier and Tier 2 DoE Matrix directly into Schedule 1 (Scope of Services) of Project Quote B, requiring the laboratory’s senior research hydrometallurgist to sign off on interim Experimental Observation and Evaluation Logs at the conclusion of each test series that explicitly address whether the empirical data confirmed or falsified the stated chemical hypothesis1.

Step 4: Experimentation Tracking, Variable Isolation & Supporting Activity Substantiation

Finally, Curnamona ensures that any supporting R&D activities claimed under section 355-30 are fully insulated against audit by IISA or the ATO4. Routine ICP-MS solution assays and XRD residue analyses performed on the outputs of the Stage Gate 2 experimental leach vessels constitute “routine testing and analysis of materials” under section 355-25(2)(f)2. Consequently, they cannot be claimed as part of the core R&D activity itself, but must be registered as supporting R&D activities under section 355-30(2)4. To discharge the evidentiary burden under section 355-30(2), Curnamona maintains a contemporaneous Sample-to-Hypothesis Traceability Ledger linking every individual ICP-MS assay invoice line item to a specific experimental vessel ID (EXP-LEACH-014) and hypothesis ID (HYP-2.3). This ledger provides irrefutable contemporaneous proof that those analytical tests were undertaken for the sole and dominant purpose of evaluating the experimental outcomes of a valid core R&D activity, rather than for routine mineral exploration or statutory compliance4.

Posted on Google Google
Daniel McGregor  profile picture
Daniel McGregor
11. August, 2022
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I have been using Swanson Reed for my clients for more than a decade. Having a specialist firm that can provide practical and commercial advice that produces real outcomes is very important and we have received great feedback from our clients. Highly recommended.
Posted on Google Google
John  profile picture
John
15. June, 2022
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Damian and the rest of the team at Swanson Reed have been supporting us for several years. We always appreciate their insights, expertise, and efforts.
Posted on Google Google
Rueben Rajasingam  profile picture
Rueben Rajasingam
6. June, 2022
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Experienced responsive Team. They have been a great help to me and my company navigate the R&D tax claim process and have provided invaluable advice.
Posted on Google Google
Enrique Esquivel  profile picture
Enrique Esquivel
6. June, 2022
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Damian and the team at Swanson Reed have been extremely helpfully and professional during all of our consultations. Highly recommended.
Posted on Google Google
Jess at Y&C  profile picture
Jess at Y&C
3. June, 2022
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Posted on Google Google
Anatole Kononewsky  profile picture
Anatole Kononewsky
2. June, 2022
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
The Swanson Reed team have provided our company with exceptional professional advice and assistance for all of our R&D claims for many years - have always achieved great results with excellent value for their services.
Posted on Google Google
Payam Toloo  profile picture
Payam Toloo
2. June, 2022
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Damian Smyth and his team are very helpful, supportive and experts in their field of R&D Tax claims. I'm always happy with the work they do and been a customer of their for over 5 years.
Posted on Google Google
Melissa Doddy  profile picture
Melissa Doddy
31. May, 2022
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
The Team at Swanson Reed are very experienced R&D Tax Advisors and gave us ongoing support with all of our R&D Claims, the consultants ensured we were always working with current legislative guidelines, gave us assistance with compiling technical and government documentation and went out their way to ensure they were with us for the entire process from beginning to end. Highly recommended to anyone who needs assistance with working through what can at times be a daunting process.
Posted on Google Google
Gary Watson  profile picture
Gary Watson
31. May, 2022
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
We can highly recommend Swanson and Reed as an R & D accountant. We have worked with them for several years now as they make our R & D claim so easy and communicate quickly with both us and our accountant.
Posted on Google Google
Rob van den Bergh  profile picture
Rob van den Bergh
31. May, 2022
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Always professional.