Statutory Eligibility, Evidentiary Substantiation, and Experimental Rigour under Division 355: A Legal and Technical Analysis of Ultimate Vision Inventions Pty Ltd and Innovation and Science Australia [2019] AATA 1633

Leading SaaS provider TechnologyOne establishes Team Australia Fund

1. Executive Summary and Case Background

1.1 Overview of the Dispute and Corporate Context

The decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) in Ultimate Vision Inventions Pty Ltd and Innovation and Science Australia (Taxation) [2019] AATA 1633, handed down on 27 June 2019 by Member A. Maryniak QC in the Taxation and Commercial Division in Melbourne, stands as a foundational compliance authority within Australia’s Research and Development Tax Incentive (R&DTI) jurisprudence1. The proceeding arose from an eligibility dispute between the applicant taxpayer, Ultimate Vision Inventions Pty Ltd (UVI), and the programme regulator, Innovation and Science Australia (ISA, subsequently styled Industry Innovation and Science Australia or IISA, operating through AusIndustry)2.

UVI was incorporated in July 2012 with Werner Nicolau serving as its sole director and shareholder5. On 1 July 2013, UVI executed a service agreement with Akyman Investments Pty Ltd, an entity directed by Werner Nicolau’s father, Mark Nicolau5. Akyman Investments Pty Ltd was registered under the Industry Research and Development Act 1986 (Cth) (IR&D Act) as a Research Service Provider (RSP)5. Relying on this corporate and contractual arrangement, UVI lodged R&D registration applications for consecutive income years—specifically the 2013–14 (FY14) and 2014–15 (FY15) financial years examined in the primary AAT proceeding, alongside a subsequent 2015–16 (FY16) registration that formed part of the broader administrative dispute—claiming both “core R&D activities” and “supporting R&D activities”3. By the 2016 income year alone, UVI claimed total notional R&D expenditure of $336,0005.

Following a formal compliance examination conducted under the IR&D Act, the regulator issued negative statutory findings determining that UVI’s registered activities did not satisfy the legislative criteria for eligible core or supporting R&D activities under Division 355 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth) (ITAA 1997)1. After the regulator’s adverse determination was confirmed upon internal review, UVI sought merits review before the AAT, where the company appeared unrepresented through Werner and Mark Nicolau3.

1.2 The Taxpayer’s Registered Project and Technical Claims

UVI’s registered project centred on the conceptualisation, design, and development of an “Integrated Health and Fitness program and Cloud-based Decision Support Systems”, referred to across regulatory filings and subsequent tribunal proceedings as the Health and Fitness System (HFS)1. The taxpayer characterised the HFS as a complex digital platform designed to integrate dietary management, physical fitness regimes, pharmaceutical prescription tracking, electronic payment functionalities, and holistic wellbeing programmes4.

From a systems architecture perspective, UVI asserted that the platform sought to combine artificial intelligence (AI), decision support systems (DSS), and cloud-based cryptographic protocols—specifically Implicit Key Management (IKM) and Point Over End (POE) architecture—to generate personalised health and fitness recommendations tailored to individual user profiles, including age, physiological metrics, activity habits, and underlying health conditions5. During the relevant registration periods examined in [2019] AATA 1633, UVI registered three core R&D activities (each paired with a corresponding supporting activity) in each income year: for the 2013–14 year, the design of fitness management algorithms for calorie consumption measurement; the design of health management algorithms for calorie intake measurement; and the conceptual design and evaluation of a potential implementation of cloud-based decision support systems; and, for the 2014–15 year, improvements of fitness monitoring algorithms and a multi-level search engine; improvements of diet monitoring algorithms and a multi-level search engine; and improvements of cloud-based anti-collision systems with “smoothing” algorithms1. UVI contended that the novelty of integrating these disparate health, fitness, and security domains, combined with the technical challenges encountered during iterative system design, demonstrated that its work constituted eligible experimental activities that generated new knowledge4.

1.3 Governing Statutory Framework under Australian Law

Australia’s R&DTI regime operates under a dual-agency co-administration model governed by Division 355 of the ITAA 1997 and Part III of the IR&D Act1. While the Commissioner of Taxation (via the Australian Taxation Office) administers expenditure quantification and refundable or non-refundable tax offset calculations under Subdivision 355-D—including the expenditure nexus requirement under section 355-205(1) of the ITAA 1997—IISA holds statutory jurisdiction under sections 27A and 27J of the IR&D Act to register activities and make binding findings regarding whether registered activities constitute eligible R&D activities5.

The substantive threshold for activity eligibility is codified in section 355-20 of the ITAA 1997, which divides eligible R&D activities into “core R&D activities” (section 355-25) and “supporting R&D activities” (section 355-30)4. Section 355-25(1) of the ITAA 1997 establishes a strict, cumulative two-limb statutory test for core R&D activities1. Under the first limb in section 355-25(1)(a), core R&D activities must be experimental activities whose outcome cannot be known or determined in advance on the basis of current knowledge, information, or experience, but can only be determined by applying a systematic progression of work that is based on principles of established science (subparagraph (i)) and proceeds from hypothesis to experiment, observation, and evaluation, and leads to logical conclusions (subparagraph (ii))1. Under the second limb in section 355-25(1)(b), those experimental activities must be conducted for the purpose of generating new knowledge, including new knowledge in the form of new or improved materials, products, devices, processes, or services3.

Furthermore, section 355-25(2) enumerates specific statutory exclusions that disqualify otherwise experimental activities from qualifying as core R&D activities, including market research, research in the social sciences, arts, or humanities, and paragraph (h), which excludes developing, modifying, or customising computer software for the dominant purpose of use by entities for their internal administration1. Under section 355-30(1) of the ITAA 1997, supporting R&D activities are defined as activities directly related to core R&D activities, subject to an additional dominant purpose requirement under section 355-30(2) if the activity falls within a section 355-25(2) exclusion or produces, or is directly related to producing, goods or services4. Because the existence of a valid supporting R&D activity is legally derivative of a valid core R&D activity, the complete absence of an eligible core R&D activity is fatal to any supporting activity claim4.

In construing section 355-25(1), the Tribunal in [2019] AATA 1633 relied on the earlier Tribunal decision in Re Moreton Resources Ltd and Innovation and Science Australia (Taxation) [2018] AATA 3378, citing it for the proposition that an activity will not be an experimental activity if it merely demonstrates a known fact or applies established methodologies in a different context; that Tribunal decision was subsequently set aside by the Full Federal Court in Moreton Resources Ltd v Innovation and Science Australia [2019] FCAFC 120, handed down on 25 July 2019, after the UVI decision of 27 June 20196. In Moreton Resources, the Full Court clarified that the word “experimental” in the opening chapeau of section 355-25(1) has minimal independent work to perform; rather, the phrase “experimental activities” is descriptive of activities that satisfy the cumulative conditions specified in paragraphs (a) and (b)6. While the Full Court in Moreton Resources later confirmed that applying existing technology at a new site or in a new context is not per se excluded from generating new knowledge, the tribunal determinations in Ultimate Vision Inventions demonstrate that a taxpayer cannot invoke broad conceptual novelty to bypass the strict evidentiary burden of proving that actual scientific experiments were conducted during the relevant income year6.

1.4 Procedural Trajectory and Final Holdings

In Ultimate Vision Inventions Pty Ltd and Innovation and Science Australia [2019] AATA 1633, Member Maryniak QC affirmed the regulator’s decision under review in its entirety1. The Tribunal held that UVI did not carry out eligible core or supporting R&D activities during the relevant income years because the taxpayer failed to substantiate that the registered activities were actually conducted, failed to establish that the outcomes could not be determined in advance on an objective basis, failed to apply a systematic progression of work grounded in established science, and failed to demonstrate a purpose of generating new knowledge3.

The subsequent appellate trajectory of the dispute underscores both its administrative law significance and the durability of the regulator’s substantive evidentiary critique. UVI initially appealed the 2019 AAT decision to the Federal Court of Australia under section 44 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), contending that the Tribunal had constructively failed to exercise its independent review jurisdiction because 64 of the 67 paragraphs in its substantive analysis were copied verbatim from ISA’s closing written submissions10. In Ultimate Vision Inventions Pty Ltd v Innovation and Science Australia [2022] FCA 606 (and the related costs judgment in [2022] FCA 669), Justice Wheelahan dismissed the appeal, observing that while verbatim adoption of a party’s submissions was “not ideal”, three structural features of the decision indicated that the Tribunal member had independently formed the views expressed10.

However, on further appeal in Ultimate Vision Inventions Pty Ltd v Innovation and Science Australia [2023] FCAFC 23 (reported at 297 FCR 143; 408 ALR 460), a Full Court of the Federal Court comprising Justices Thawley, McElwaine, and Hespe overturned the primary judge’s orders on 2 March 202311. The Full Court held that the Tribunal’s unattributed verbatim copying of 64 out of 67 paragraphs of the respondent’s submissions, unaccompanied by any explanation as to why the respondent’s contentions were preferred over the applicant’s, constituted a constructive failure to discharge its statutory task of independent merits review11. Noting that the Tribunal’s assertion that it had undertaken a “thorough analysis” carried “the air of formulaic incantation”, the Full Court set aside the AAT decision and remitted the matter for rehearing4. Following the replacement of the AAT by the Administrative Review Tribunal (ART) in October 2024, the remitted proceedings covering the 2014, 2015, and 2016 income years were heard afresh in Ultimate Vision Inventions Pty Ltd v Industry, Innovation and Science Australia (Taxation) [2025] ARTA 1813 (decided 17 September 2025)4. Despite UVI engaging Senior Counsel and tendering expert reports from software architecture consultant Dr Paul Nash, the ART—relying on expert evidence from Professor Deborah Kerr and Professor Jean-Guy Schneider—once again affirmed IISA’s decision in full, holding that none of UVI’s activities were conducted as registered or satisfied Division 3552.

 

Procedural Stage & Citation Decision Date & Forum Presiding Bench / Member Core Legal Issue & Disposition
Primary Merits Review

Ultimate Vision Inventions Pty Ltd and Innovation and Science Australia [2019] AATA 1633

27 June 2019

Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Taxation & Commercial Division)1

Member A. Maryniak QC1 Affirmed Regulator’s Negative Finding: Held UVI failed to prove registered HFS activities were conducted or met the criteria for core/supporting R&D under ss 355-25 and 355-30 of the ITAA 19971.
Federal Court Appeal (Single Judge)

Ultimate Vision Inventions Pty Ltd v Innovation and Science Australia [2022] FCA 606; [2022] FCA 669

24 May 2022 (Merits)

9 June 2022 (Costs)

Federal Court of Australia10

Justice Wheelahan10 Appeal Dismissed: Held that while the AAT copying 64 of 67 paragraphs from ISA’s submissions was “not ideal”, the Tribunal had not failed to bring an independent mind to the review11.
Full Federal Court Appeal

Ultimate Vision Inventions Pty Ltd v Innovation and Science Australia [2023] FCAFC 23

2 March 2023

Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia14

Justices Thawley, McElwaine, and Hespe14 Appeal Allowed & Remitted: Held unattributed verbatim replication of 64 of 67 paragraphs of respondent submissions constituted a constructive failure to exercise statutory merits review jurisdiction4.
Remitted Merits Rehearing

Ultimate Vision Inventions Pty Ltd v Industry, Innovation and Science Australia [2025] ARTA 1813

17 September 2025

Administrative Review Tribunal15

Administrative Review Tribunal (Taxation Division)4 Affirmed Regulator’s Negative Finding Afresh: Upon full de novo examination of expert testimony, held no core or supporting R&D activities were conducted or eligible in FY14, FY15, or FY164.

2. Core Legal, Technical, and Evidentiary Failures

A granular examination of [2019] AATA 1633 (specifically at paragraphs [82], [87]–[88], and [94]–[97]), read alongside the expanded expert record in the remitted proceedings, reveals seven intersecting legal, technical, contractual, and documentation deficiencies that resulted in the total disqualification of UVI’s R&D claims3.

2.1 Failure to Substantiate Conduct of Registered Activities and Absence of Technical Artefacts

Under the self-assessment architecture of Division 355, a threshold factual requirement is that the taxpayer must establish, on the balance of probabilities, that the specific activities described in its R&D registration application were actually conducted during the relevant income year3. Throughout the compliance examination and Tribunal review, UVI failed to describe its registered activities consistently and could not align its working documents with the registered core activities3.

Although UVI tendered a voluminous nine-volume “R&D Manual” comprising working papers and technical notes, the Tribunal found that sheer documentary volume could not substitute for probative technical substance4. Only a small fraction of the nine-volume manual actually related to the registered HFS activities4. More critically, independent expert evaluation by Associate Professor Jean-Guy Schneider (as he is described in [2019] AATA 1633), a software engineering expert, exposed a complete absence of verifiable software engineering artefacts5. UVI agreed that it never produced an application or source code, and therefore had nothing on which to conduct alpha and beta testing, while the two ‘test templates’ for the ‘Cloud Server APP’ did not actually record any testing or experimentation5. Dr Schneider drew a fundamental technical distinction between “high-level” conceptual flowcharts and implementable algorithms5. UVI’s documentation consisted of diagrams, flow charts, a draft conceptual design document, mislabelled functional specifications and successive draft detailed design documents that showed very little progression and recorded no actual experimental activity; Dr Schneider considered that the flow charts contained a multitude of non-trivial decision points and had not been developed to a point where they could be implemented, and that a purely ‘desktop’ methodology without source code would not be sufficient to design and test the application’s functionality4.

2.2 Absence of Technological Uncertainty and Determinability of Outcomes in Advance

Section 355-25(1)(a) of the ITAA 1997 mandates that the outcome of a core R&D activity “cannot be known or determined in advance on the basis of current knowledge, information or experience”3. Australian tax jurisprudence establishes that this statutory test is strictly objective6. It is not satisfied by the subjective state of mind or personal knowledge gaps of the taxpayer’s directors (Werner and Mark Nicolau); rather, the inquiry asks whether a competent professional skilled in the relevant scientific or technological field could deduce or determine the outcome in advance by drawing upon publicly available global knowledge, authoritative literature, or standard engineering experience4.

UVI failed this objective threshold across both its nutritional and fitness algorithms and its cloud architecture4. In conducting its background research, UVI relied primarily on a superficial survey of existing commercial health and fitness systems copied directly from online sources with minimal original analysis of underlying scientific or mathematical limitations4. Regarding the first two registered core activities (the design of fitness and health management algorithms for calorie consumption and intake measurement), IISA’s expert witness Dr Deborah Kerr (as she is described in [2019] AATA 1633), an expert in nutrition and dietetics, demonstrated that, as at 1 July 2013, it was well known that energy expenditure is largely dependent on an individual’s resting metabolic rate, which in turn depends on age, gender and size and is influenced by life stages and disease conditions; that published scientific papers already dealt with the impact of humidity, elevation and temperature on metabolic rate; that merely keeping a food log was nothing new; and that measuring which existing calorie-prediction equation is most accurate was not novel or capable of generating new knowledge3. Dr Kerr also found that the purported ‘algorithms’ produced from these activities were so deficient that she did not recognise them as algorithms, and the Tribunal found that, had UVI consulted an expert, it would have been informed that the outcomes of registered activities 1.1 and 1.2 could have been known in advance4. Similarly, regarding the third core activity (conceptual design and evaluation of a potential implementation of cloud-based decision support systems in the 2013–14 year, and improvements of cloud-based anti-collision systems with ‘smoothing’ algorithms in the 2014–15 year), Dr Schneider’s compelling evidence was that there was insufficient evidence of what, if anything, was done by way of experimental activity to evaluate whether the outcome could have been known in advance; he nevertheless opined that the use of a cloud-based decision support system was not novel, that client-server type architectures were nothing new, that there was nothing particularly unusual about the proposed system, and that anti-collision and smoothing algorithms already existed in software systems in other domains before June 20135.

2.3 Lack of a Systematic Progression of Work and Deficient Experimental Methodology

Even where technical uncertainty exists, section 355-25(1)(a)(i)–(ii) requires that the uncertainty can only be resolved by applying a “systematic progression of work that is based on principles of established science; and proceeds from hypothesis to experiment, observation and evaluation, and leads to logical conclusions”1. The Tribunal identified fatal methodological defects in UVI’s purported testing regime3. UVI’s technical records lacked a structured scientific framework linking defined hypotheses, experimental parameters, empirical observations, and analytical conclusions4.

In attempting to substantiate experimental testing of its dietary and caloric algorithms, UVI relied on exercise test record forms completed by no more than two or three members of the Nicolau family (with conflicting evidence as to whether Werner Nicolau’s mother participated) and, for its dietary activity, on Mark Nicolau following a diet that a dietician had given him for his own personal health issues4. The Tribunal rejected this contention, finding that the sample was not sufficiently large, the test subjects did not necessarily follow the stipulated exercise program, no objective baseline measurements of calorie consumption (or of basal metabolic rate) were established, environmental conditions were not accurately measured, the forms recorded only subjective handwritten annotations such as ‘high sweat’ and ‘v. windy’, and there was no attempt to measure the exact amount of food consumed, convert it into calories or record when it was consumed; UVI itself admitted that none of this activity was carried out in accordance with the principles of established exercise or dietary science3. Because the sample size was minute, the recorded results were vague, and no meaningful analysis was performed, the adequacy and reliability of any conclusions drawn were fundamentally compromised3. Furthermore, UVI argued that, in software engineering, experiments are carried out for each development phase—conceptual design, functional specifications and detailed design, followed by test planning, source code testing and alpha and beta testing—and that its R&D Manuals evidenced such a progression7. The Tribunal rejected this contention, finding that UVI never produced an application or source code on which alpha and beta testing could be performed, that merely drafting documents is not an experimental activity, and that the question is not whether UVI had an idea that could be characterised as ‘innovative’ but whether the registered activities were actually conducted and met the statutory definition7. Iterative prototyping directed toward achieving a functional commercial design, resolving design flaws, or enhancing usability constitutes routine engineering refinement, whereas statutory experimentation requires a controlled investigation structured to test scientific or technical hypotheses and resolve unknown technical principles7.

2.4 Failure to Establish the Purpose of Generating New Knowledge vs. Routine Engineering

Under section 355-25(1)(b) of the ITAA 1997, core R&D activities must be conducted “for the purpose of generating new knowledge”3. As underscored in paragraphs [43], [80], [88] and [97] of [2019] AATA 1633, the taxpayer bears the evidentiary burden of producing objective, contemporaneous documentation proving that its purpose at the time the activities were undertaken was to generate new technical or scientific knowledge, rather than merely developing a commercial product using existing knowledge6.

The Tribunal found that there was no objective evidence that UVI had a purpose of generating new knowledge in relation to registered activities 1.2 and 1.3, and that in relation to activity 1.1 UVI was, at best, indifferent to whether any knowledge generated through its field tests was new4. Practical learning gained by a developer when an early-stage prototype fails or undergoes iterative design modification is typically confined to the specific product under development and does not yield generalisable scientific or technical principles required to constitute statutory “new knowledge”7. Because UVI’s activities consisted of family members informally recording their exercise and diet, at most testing existing measures, and drafting design documents for a cloud-based system whose architecture was not novel, there was no objective, contemporaneous evidence that they were directed toward the generation of new knowledge—meaning knowledge not already available in the public domain on a reasonably accessible worldwide basis, rather than knowledge new only to UVI4.

2.5 Temporal Mismatches, Income-Year Ring-Fencing, and Retrospective Reconstruction

A pervasive error among R&DTI claimants is treating a multi-year R&D project as an undifferentiated whole. Before the Tribunal, UVI argued that IISA and the Tribunal were required to evaluate the “totality” of the multi-year HFS project across all years4. The Tribunal rejected this submission, affirming the statutory principle of strict income-year ring-fencing: under Division 355 and the IR&D Act, eligibility is evaluated strictly on the registered activities conducted within each specific income year under review3. Earlier R&D activities are only relevant to the limited extent that they directly clarify the activities actually performed during the income year under review4.

UVI’s evidentiary record suffered from acute temporal inconsistencies that undermined its credibility3. Witness statements supplied by UVI comprised conclusory assertions expressed in general terms, its technical documents showed very little progression in the work, and UVI’s own witnesses conceded that the dates on the documents did not necessarily correspond to the actual date of the document3. Notably, the evidence concerning when the health and fitness ‘field tests’ (or ‘pilot program’) began was inconsistent and confusing, Mark Nicolau ultimately admitted that he had no independent recollection of when the work began, neither witness appeared to know when testing ended, and UVI could not explain how registered Activity 1.3—which its registrations framed as merging the outputs of Activities 1.1 and 1.2—could begin before those activities were complete4. Moreover, during the remitted ART proceedings, UVI relied on two expert reports from Dr Paul Nash, who constructed a custom framework of “content types” and “development phases” to map UVI’s deliverables to the registered activities, contending that the project followed an industry-standard “iterative waterfall” methodology5. The Tribunal rejected Dr Nash’s mapping because it relied heavily on retrospective interpretation and ex-post facto assumptions rather than contemporaneous records created during the relevant income years, rendering his described methodology aspirational rather than evidenced in practice5.

2.6 Contractual Ambiguity, Related-Party RSP Governance, and External Entity Documentation

The corporate and contractual arrangements surrounding UVI introduced further evidentiary deficiencies4. Although UVI entered into a service agreement on 1 July 2013 with Akyman Investments Pty Ltd—a registered RSP directed by Mark Nicolau—the invoices produced by Akyman were unreliable—by Mark Nicolau’s own admission they included work not actually performed—and the witness statements contained insufficient direct evidence of what was actually done by UVI or Akyman in the relevant years, substantially diminishing their evidentiary value in proving that registered R&D activities were conducted and incurred within the relevant financial years4. Compounding this ambiguity, UVI relied on material relating to activities not mentioned in its registrations, including documents relating to Near Field Communication (NFC) work performed by Akyman on behalf of a different company, a transaction card processing system, a ‘Find Phone Mobile App’, a ‘ZAP contract mobile APP’ and a ‘power socket rotative adaptor’, as well as material relating to its 2016 year registration4. The Tribunal found that this material was irrelevant to whether any of UVI’s registered activities were conducted in the relevant years and that UVI’s continued reliance on it, in an impermissible attempt to extend the scope of its activities, only highlighted the lack of material relating to the actual registered activities4.

2.7 Consequential Disqualification of Supporting R&D Activities

Finally, UVI registered supporting R&D activities across the relevant income years4. Under section 355-30(1) of the ITAA 1997, an activity only qualifies as a supporting R&D activity if it is directly related to eligible core R&D activities5. Because the Tribunal determined that no eligible core R&D activities were conducted by UVI during either of the relevant income years, it held that it need not consider whether any supporting R&D activities were conducted, as the statutory nexus required by section 355-30(1) could not be satisfied, resulting in the failure of all claimed supporting activities4.

3. Comparative Summary Table of Statutory Requirements, Taxpayer Deficiencies, and Evidentiary Standards

The following table maps each statutory requirement under the ITAA 1997 and the IR&D Act examined in the Ultimate Vision Inventions litigation against UVI’s specific factual and evidentiary failures and the corresponding legal standard of proof enforced by the Tribunal.

 

Statutory Provision & Legal Requirement Taxpayer’s Specific Failure in Ultimate Vision Inventions Tribunal’s Standard of Proof & Evidentiary Benchmark
Conduct of Registered Activities

IR&D Act 1986 (Cth) ss 27A, 27J;

ITAA 1997 (Cth) s 355-205(1)

UVI provided inconsistent activity descriptions across the review; submitted a 9-volume “R&D Manual” mostly irrelevant to the HFS project; failed to produce any source code, executable prototypes, implementable algorithms, or test logs; and relied on flow charts, diagrams and mislabelled functional specification and draft detailed design documents that had not been developed to a point where they could be implemented and recorded no actual testing3. Strict Factual & Technical Substantiation: The applicant must prove on the balance of probabilities via contemporaneous technical artefacts (source code repositories, commit logs, executable builds, test harnesses, and formal architectural notations) that the exact activities registered for that specific income year were physically performed beyond mere conceptual ideation3.
Outcome Cannot Be Known or Determined in Advance

ITAA 1997 (Cth) s 355-25(1)(a)

UVI copied generic online surveys of existing fitness apps without critical analysis; sought to test matters already well known or published before 1 July 2013 (the dependence of energy expenditure on resting metabolic rate, age, gender and size, the effect of humidity, elevation and temperature on metabolic rate, and food logging); and proposed a cloud-based decision support system, client-server architecture and anti-collision and smoothing algorithms that were not novel4. Objective Global Expert Standard: The test is strictly objective, not based on the taxpayer’s subjective state of mind6. The taxpayer must demonstrate—supported by comprehensive prior art searches and independent expert evidence—that a competent professional in the relevant scientific/technical field could not determine the outcome in advance using existing global knowledge, information, or experience3.
Systematic Progression of Work Based on Established Science

ITAA 1997 (Cth) s 355-25(1)(a)(i)–(ii)

UVI failed to formulate verifiable hypotheses or link objectives, methods, observations, and conclusions4. Its purported “experiments” consisted of no more than two or three Nicolau family members completing exercise test record forms and Mark Nicolau following a diet given to him for his own health issues, yielding subjective, vague results, a statistically invalid sample size, and no meaningful analysis3. UVI also characterised software engineering development phases (conceptual design, functional specifications and detailed design) as experiments, although it never produced an application or source code7. Controlled Scientific Method: The taxpayer must evidence a structured, hypothesis-driven experimental protocol grounded in established science (e.g., computer science, biostatistics, nutrition science)5. Testing must isolate variables, utilise statistically valid sample sizes and control benchmarks, record empirical quantitative metrics, and evaluate data to reach logical scientific conclusions3.
Purpose of Generating New Knowledge

ITAA 1997 (Cth) s 355-25(1)(b)

(See [2019] AATA 1633 at [43], [80], [88], [97])

UVI lacked objective contemporaneous records establishing a knowledge-generating purpose6. The Tribunal found no objective, contemporaneous evidence of a purpose of generating new knowledge for activities 1.2 and 1.3, and found that UVI was at best indifferent to whether any knowledge generated through its activity 1.1 field tests was new4. Contemporaneous Purpose of Generalisable Advancement: The taxpayer must prove via contemporaneous planning and governance records that the activities were undertaken for the purpose of generating new knowledge that goes beyond merely applying existing knowledge or resolving product-specific functional design flaws6.
Income-Year Temporal Ring-Fencing

ITAA 1997 (Cth) ss 355-25, 355-205;

IR&D Act 1986 (Cth) s 27A

UVI argued that the Tribunal should assess the “totality” of the multi-year project; relied on documents whose dates did not necessarily correspond to their actual dates and on a witness statement relating to the 2016 year, which was not before the Tribunal; gave inconsistent and confusing evidence about when its field tests began and ended; and relied on Dr Paul Nash’s retrospective expert mapping3. Strict Annualised Assessment & Contemporaneity: Eligibility is evaluated strictly per income year4. Evidence must be created contemporaneously within the relevant financial year3. Retrospective reconstruction by advisers or experts at the point of claim or litigation carries minimal weight if unsupported by primary records from the relevant income year5.
Entity Ownership & Contractual Nexus

ITAA 1997 (Cth) ss 355-205, 355-210

UVI relied on irrelevant material relating to activities not in its registrations, including NFC work performed by Akyman on behalf of a different company; and relied on invoices from its related-party RSP (Akyman Investments Pty Ltd) that, by Mark Nicolau’s own admission, included work not actually performed4. Clear IP Title & Granular Contractual Specificity: The R&D entity must establish legal/beneficial ownership or control of the R&D results and ensure that third-party or related-party RSP contracts, statements of work, and invoices explicitly itemise the registered core/supporting activities, experimental milestones, and exact dates of service delivery4.
Supporting R&D Activities Nexus

ITAA 1997 (Cth) s 355-30(1)–(2)

UVI claimed supporting activities (background research, system planning, conceptual evaluation) when no valid core R&D activities were found to have been conducted during the relevant income years4. Derivative Direct Relationship: Supporting R&D activities cannot exist in a vacuum4. The taxpayer must first establish at least one valid, conducted core R&D activity under s 355-25, and then prove via contemporaneous records a direct causal and functional relationship (and, where applicable under s 355-30(2), a dominant purpose) supporting that core activity4.

4. Applied Remedial Case Studies

To demonstrate how Australian corporate taxpayers and R&D tax advisers can operationalise the legal and technical principles handed down in Ultimate Vision Inventions, the following two industry case studies model projects confronting the exact statutory pitfalls identified by the Tribunal. Each case study provides a step-by-step remedial blueprint across project governance, technical documentation, contractual structuring, and experimental tracking to achieve full compliance under Division 355 of the ITAA 1997.

4.1 Case Study 1: Biometric and Algorithmic Clinical Decision Support Software (MedTech / Digital Health)

Project Scenario and Inherent Legal Vulnerabilities

A Melbourne-based digital health company, NutriPulse Analytics Pty Ltd, is developing an integrated mobile and cloud platform that ingests continuous photoplethysmography (PPG) heart-rate waveforms and 3-axis accelerometer telemetry from consumer wearable devices alongside user-captured smartphone photographs of meals. The commercial objective is to predict postprandial glycaemic excursions and real-time caloric expenditure for Type 2 diabetes management.

In its initial posture, NutriPulse’s engineering and management team falls into the exact traps that disqualified UVI in [2019] AATA 16333. Management proposes registering broad, functional activity descriptions framed as the “Design of health and fitness algorithms for calorie intake and consumption measurement”3. Their initial software build encodes standard Harris-Benedict and Mifflin-St Jeor basal metabolic rate equations alongside public nutritional lookup tables—outcomes that any competent dietitian or software engineer can determine in advance4. To test the prototype, the two founding directors log their own meals and gym workouts over a three-week period in an unlabelled spreadsheet4. Furthermore, NutriPulse outsources algorithm coding to a related-party consultancy owned by a founder’s relative under a generic two-page retainer agreement that bills a flat monthly fee for “Software Development & R&D Services”4. If audited by IISA, NutriPulse’s claim would be disallowed in its entirety on the authority of Ultimate Vision Inventions3.

Step 1: Project Governance and Pre-Registration Prior Art Benchmarking

To satisfy the objective threshold in section 355-25(1)(a) of the ITAA 1997—establishing that the outcome could not be known or determined in advance by a competent professional in the field—NutriPulse must constitute a formal R&D Governance Committee prior to commencing experimental work in the income year and execute a rigorous, documented literature and prior art review4. The governance committee must first segregate routine software engineering tasks—such as user-interface wireframing, encoding deterministic Mifflin-St Jeor caloric equations, standard REST API integration, and relational database design—into a non-R&D commercial cost centre so that they are excluded from core R&D registration4.

Rather than copying descriptions of commercial fitness applications from online sources as UVI did, NutriPulse’s lead biomedical data scientist and an external accredited practising dietitian must author a formal State-of-the-Art Technical Baseline Report dated prior to experimental commencement4. This report must review peer-reviewed biomedical engineering and clinical nutrition literature demonstrating why consumer wearable PPG sensors suffer from severe motion-artefact signal corruption during non-steady-state movement, and why monocular smartphone food photography cannot deterministically calculate volumetric density or hidden lipid content using existing convolutional neural network (CNN) architectures. Concurrently, the Board of Directors must pass and minute a formal resolution prior to experimental commencement recording that the specific purpose of the upcoming experimental programme is to generate new mathematical and computer science knowledge regarding motion-artefact signal denoising and volumetric macronutrient estimation in accordance with section 355-25(1)(b), distinct from commercial application deployment6.

Step 2: Structuring the Systematic Progression of Work and Experimental Protocol

To overcome the Tribunal’s rejection of UVI’s reliance on informal exercise and diet records of two or three family members and lack of scientific method, NutriPulse must replace ad-hoc functional prototyping with a formal, biostatistically valid experimental protocol grounded in computer science and human physiology under section 355-25(1)(a)(i)–(ii)4. NutriPulse must articulate a precise, falsifiable hypothesis in its registration and project charter, such as: “It is hypothesised that coupling an adaptive Kalman filter with a Long Short-Term Memory (LSTM) recurrent neural network trained on raw 3-axis accelerometer and green-wavelength PPG waveforms can isolate motion-induced haemodynamic noise during non-steady-state exercise, reducing caloric expenditure estimation error to within of indirect calorimetry ( metabolic cart baseline) across diverse metabolic phenotypes.”

Instead of logging two company directors, NutriPulse must partner with a university exercise physiology laboratory under ethics approval to conduct a controlled trial involving a statistically powered cohort (for example, stratified human subjects across defined age, body mass index, and insulin-sensitivity brackets)4. The experimental protocol must hold hardware sampling rates constant (), systematically isolate independent variables (such as Kalman filter process noise covariance matrices, LSTM hidden layer dimensionality, and dropout regularisation rates), and measure empirical outputs against an objective scientific gold standard (continuous indirect calorimetry gas analysis and continuous glucose monitoring interstitial fluid sensors)4. Each experimental iteration must evaluate algorithmic predictions using rigorous statistical error metrics—specifically Root Mean Square Error (), Mean Absolute Percentage Error (), and Bland-Altman limits of agreement—documenting why specific algorithmic configurations failed (such as phase-lag distortion at heart rates exceeding ) and how those falsified hypotheses informed the subsequent mathematical iteration3.

Step 3: Contemporaneous Technical Documentation and Software Artefact Capture

To neutralise the evidentiary failures identified by Dr Schneider in Ultimate Vision Inventions regarding the absence of source code and of algorithms developed to a point where they could be implemented, NutriPulse must enforce automated, timestamped technical artefact capture throughout the income year4. All system architectures, data pipelines, and algorithmic state machines must be documented using formal Unified Modeling Language (UML 2.5) sequence and class diagrams, accompanied by explicit mathematical notation defining the state-space equations5.

Crucially, NutriPulse must maintain a dedicated, version-controlled Git repository where every experimental branch, pull request, and commit message is tagged with the specific R&D Hypothesis ID and Core Activity ID (for example, [Core-Act-01][Hyp-1.2] Implement adaptive covariance matrix scaling in Kalman-LSTM fusion layer). This practice creates an immutable, timestamped audit trail proving that implementable algorithms and executable source code were written and tested within the relevant income year4. Alongside the code repository, NutriPulse must archive raw and processed telemetry datasets, Python experimental notebooks, automated continuous integration test logs, and statistical evaluation matrices with immutable server timestamps, establishing an unbroken chain of contemporaneous evidence from hypothesis to logical conclusion3.

Step 4: Contractual Alignment and Research Service Provider (RSP) Management

To avoid the contractual and entity-ownership defects that undermined UVI’s arrangement with Akyman Investments Pty Ltd, NutriPulse must restructure its legal agreements with its related-party contractor prior to the start of the financial year4. The generic retainer agreement must be replaced with a formal Master R&D Services Agreement supported by quarterly Statements of Work (SoWs) executed before each experimental phase begins4. Each SoW must explicitly specify the exact core or supporting R&D activities to be performed, the scientific hypotheses under investigation, the required technical deliverables (compiled source code modules, test datasets, and statistical evaluation reports), and the strict income-year performance window4.

Furthermore, the contract must expressly vest 100% of legal and beneficial ownership of all foreground intellectual property, source code, experimental data, and know-how in NutriPulse Analytics Pty Ltd upon creation, satisfying the “on own behalf” requirements of section 355-210 of the ITAA 1997 and preventing the reliance on another company’s project material seen in UVI4. The agreement must also confirm that NutriPulse bears the financial and technical risk of experimental failure. Finally, the RSP must issue monthly invoices accompanied by daily engineer timesheets that allocate hours directly to specific registered Core Activity IDs, Supporting Activity IDs, and excluded commercial development tasks, enabling robust expenditure apportionment under section 355-205(1) of the ITAA 19974.

4.2 Case Study 2: Cloud-Based Cryptographic Key Management and Edge Telemetry Architecture (Cybersecurity / Industrial IoT)

Project Scenario and Inherent Legal Vulnerabilities

A Sydney-based industrial technology company, AegisGrid Systems Pty Ltd, is developing a cloud-based decision support and cryptographic telemetry platform for distributed renewable energy microgrids. The system seeks to utilise lightweight cryptographic protocols—analogous to the Implicit Key Management (IKM) and Point Over End (POE) architectures referenced by UVI—to authenticate real-time fault-detection decision support commands across low-power edge microcontrollers5.

Without specialist legal and technical intervention, AegisGrid’s R&D claim exhibits four acute vulnerabilities identified in Ultimate Vision Inventions3. First, AegisGrid registers “Conceptual design and evaluation of a potential implementation of Cloud-based decision support systems” as its core R&D activity3. Second, its engineering work during the first income year (FY25) consists entirely of drafting high-level architectural whitepapers, network diagrams, and adapting standard open-source Transport Layer Security (TLS 1.3) and AES-256 libraries into cloud instances—tasks resembling those for which Dr Schneider found in UVI that cloud-based decision support systems and client-server architectures were nothing new, and that a purely ‘desktop’ methodology without source code could not design and test an application’s functionality5. Third, when preparing its FY25 R&D registration, AegisGrid bundles together feasibility studies drafted in FY23 by a sister company alongside preliminary hardware bench tests conducted in August of FY26, arguing that the regulator must assess the “totality” of the multi-year microgrid project3. Fourth, AegisGrid claims $250,000 in supporting R&D activities (project management, cloud hosting, and requirement gathering) for FY25, even though actual experimental coding and packet-loss stress testing do not commence until FY264. Under the principles established in [2019] AATA 1633 and [2025] ARTA 1813, both the core and supporting claims for FY25 would be disallowed in full3.

Step 1: Isolating Core Experimental Activities from Routine System Integration

AegisGrid must immediately abandon the registration of “conceptual design and evaluation” as a core R&D activity, as conceptual design alone does not involve controlled scientific experimentation3. Instead, AegisGrid must re-architect its technical scope to isolate genuine computer science uncertainty from routine cloud configuration5. In distributed energy systems, standard TLS 1.3 handshakes and public-key infrastructure (PKI) certificate exchanges introduce computational overhead and latency exceeding on constrained 32-bit ARM Cortex-M4 edge microcontrollers operating over lossy narrowband IoT (NB-IoT) links, causing microgrid frequency-stabilisation relays to trip before decision-support commands arrive. The genuine technological uncertainty is whether a novel, stateless implicit key derivation algorithm combined with deterministic rule-tree pruning can achieve cryptographic authentication and fault-isolation execution within a hard real-time sub- latency envelope without compromising 128-bit cryptographic entropy.

High-level architectural design, mathematical modelling of the protocol prior to coding, and building the cloud testbed environment must be properly classified as supporting R&D activities under section 355-30(1) of the ITAA 1997—and must only be claimed in an income year where the linked core experimental testing is validly registered and conducted, or where a strict statutory nexus to a valid core activity is contemporaneously established4.

Step 2: Formulating Verifiable Hypotheses and Controlled Benchmarking Environments

To ensure its development cycles are not dismissed as routine iterative prototyping or as mere drafting of design documents without source code (conceptual design, functional specifications and detailed design), as was rejected in Ultimate Vision Inventions, AegisGrid must structure its software engineering around controlled experimental benchmarks5. AegisGrid must formulate a testable scientific hypothesis, such as: “It is hypothesised that replacing asymmetric elliptic-curve Diffie-Hellman (ECDH) session negotiation with a time-synchronised, hash-chain implicit key reconstruction algorithm over UDP will reduce packet payload overhead by and guarantee command execution under latency across simulated NB-IoT channels exhibiting up to stochastic packet loss, while maintaining resistance to replay and man-in-the-middle cryptanalysis.”

Rather than deploying code into production and observing general usability, AegisGrid must construct a controlled Hardware-in-the-Loop (HIL) network emulator5. Independent variables—including network jitter, bit-error rates, packet drop percentages, key rotation frequency, and microcontroller clock speeds—must be systematically varied across hundreds of automated test runs4. The engineering team must record quantitative empirical observations (CPU cycle counts, RAM heap allocation, cryptographic verification latency in microseconds, and false-rejection rates) and perform formal cryptanalytic verification using automated cryptographic protocol verifiers. This structured methodology generates generalisable computer science knowledge regarding lightweight cryptographic performance under constrained real-time conditions, satisfying section 355-25(1)(b)5.

Step 3: Version-Controlled Engineering Notation and Income-Year Ring-Fencing

To prevent the fatal temporal mismatches and income-year ring-fencing failures that defeated UVI, AegisGrid must enforce strict chronological boundaries around each financial year from 1 July to 30 June3. If FY25 consists solely of conceptual feasibility studies and preparatory system design without any core experimental testing being conducted, AegisGrid must recognise that supporting activities cannot be claimed in the absence of a valid core R&D activity4. AegisGrid must ensure its FY25 and FY26 registrations accurately reflect the exact activities physically performed within each discrete 12-month period, never tendering FY23 background documents or FY26 bench tests as evidence of FY25 conduct3.

Project Gantt charts, issue-tracking sprint logs, Git commit histories, and test bench execution logs must be audited at the conclusion of each quarter to verify chronological consistency4. Unlike UVI—whose witnesses gave inconsistent evidence about when its field tests began and could not explain how Activity 1.3 could begin before Activities 1.1 and 1.2 were complete—AegisGrid’s project governance system must enforce a sequential stage-gate workflow progressing from literature review and hypothesis sign-off, to testbed setup, to core experimental execution and observation, and finally to statistical evaluation and logical conclusions4. Rather than engaging an external consultant years later to construct an “iterative waterfall” mapping framework over disorganised working papers as Dr Nash attempted in UVI, AegisGrid must require its lead systems architect to complete a contemporaneous Monthly R&D Experimental Progress Log signed off at the end of each calendar month during the income year5.

Step 4: Inter-Company IP Demarcation and Expenditure Substantiation

To eliminate the entity-alignment defect where UVI relied on material relating to NFC work performed by Akyman on behalf of a different company and to other projects not mentioned in its registrations, AegisGrid must formalise its corporate group intellectual property and cost-sharing arrangements prior to the start of the income year4. Any background patents, feasibility plans, or hardware specifications originated by AegisGrid’s sister company in FY23 must be formally assigned or licensed to AegisGrid Systems Pty Ltd via a stamped, arm’s-length Background IP Licence Agreement executed before FY25 R&D activities commence4. Furthermore, those historical FY23 documents must be explicitly segregated and labelled as background context only, never presented as primary evidence of R&D activities conducted in FY254. For every supporting activity claimed—such as developing the HIL network emulator software or generating synthetic fault telemetry—AegisGrid’s contemporaneous work tickets must explicitly document the direct causal relationship (and, where software exclusions or production activities under section 355-30(2) are triggered, the dominant purpose) linking that specific task to the execution of the registered cryptographic core experiment4.

4.3 Summary Comparison of Remedial Governance Transformations

The table below contrasts the non-compliant practices penalised in Ultimate Vision Inventions against the remedial compliance protocols established in Case Studies 1 and 2.

 

Compliance Dimension Non-Compliant Practice in Ultimate Vision Inventions Remedial Best-Practice Protocol (Case Studies 1 & 2)
Activity Registration & Framing Broad, functional product descriptions (“Design of algorithms for calorie measurement”; “Conceptual design of cloud decision support”)3. Narrow, hypothesis-driven registration statements isolating specific scientific/technical uncertainties from routine commercial software engineering3.
Prior Art & Advance Determinability Superficial copying of competitor app descriptions from websites; testing matters (resting metabolic rate dependence, environmental effects on metabolic rate, food logging, cloud-based client-server decision support) already well known or published before 1 July 20134. Pre-commencement State-of-the-Art Technical Baseline Report citing peer-reviewed scientific literature to prove objective technological uncertainty4.
Experimental Execution & Sample Validity Informal exercise logging by two or three Nicolau family members and Mark Nicolau following a diet for his own health, with subjective observations and no statistical rigour3. Statistically powered clinical/empirical cohorts or controlled Hardware-in-the-Loop (HIL) emulators isolating variables against gold-standard benchmarks (, )3.
Technical Artefacts & Notation 9-volume manual of mostly irrelevant papers; flowcharts not developed to an implementable point; zero source code, executable prototypes, or test logs4. Formal UML 2.5 architectural schemas, mathematical specifications, Git repositories tagged by Hypothesis ID, compiled test builds, and automated CI test logs4.
Temporal & Income-Year Control Documents whose dates did not correspond to their actual dates; inconsistent evidence on when field tests began and ended; reliance on retrospective expert mapping3. Strict 1 July–30 June income-year ring-fencing; sequential stage-gate timestamps; and mandatory monthly contemporaneous sign-offs by lead engineers3.
Contractual & Entity Alignment Akyman invoices that, by admission, included work not actually performed; reliance on material about NFC work Akyman performed for a different company4. Pre-executed Master R&D Agreements and granular Statements of Work with RSPs; explicit foreground IP vesting; itemised activity-coded timesheets; and formal background IP licences4.

5. Authoritative Conclusions for Australian R&D Tax Practice

The protracted litigation in Ultimate Vision Inventions Pty Ltd—spanning the initial AAT determination in [2019] AATA 1633, the Federal Court appeals in [2022] FCA 606 and [2023] FCAFC 23, and the definitive ART remittal decision in [2025] ARTA 1813—cements several foundational principles for Australian R&D tax practitioners and corporate claimants1. Foremost among these is that procedural victory on administrative law grounds cannot cure substantive evidentiary bankruptcy4. While UVI successfully established before the Full Federal Court in [2023] FCAFC 23 that the original Tribunal failed to discharge its statutory review task by copying 64 of 67 paragraphs of the regulator’s submissions verbatim, that procedural triumph proved entirely pyrrhic upon remittal4. Even with Senior Counsel representation and independent expert witness testimony at the 2025 ART rehearing, the underlying absence of contemporaneous technical records, executable source code, and scientific methodology guaranteed the complete disallowance of the claim4.

Second, the ruling reinforces the strict doctrinal separation between commercial invention and scientific experimentation under Division 355 of the ITAA 19977. The R&DTI regime does not subsidise commercial ideation, conceptual system architecture, or iterative trial-and-error prototyping aimed at resolving design flaws or improving functional usability5. To qualify under section 355-25(1), software and engineering claimants must demonstrate a controlled scientific investigation that tests a formal hypothesis by isolating independent variables and evaluating empirical observations to generate generalisable new knowledge4.

Finally, the Ultimate Vision Inventions litigation establishes the absolute primacy of primary technical artefacts and strict annualised compliance over retrospective narrative volume4. Regulators and review tribunals accord no evidentiary weight to voluminous, uncurated working manuals or ex-post facto expert reconstructions when fundamental technical artefacts—compiled source code, version-control logs, formal software engineering notations, and statistically valid experimental test datasets—are absent4. Because IISA and the Tribunal evaluate R&D eligibility strictly within the boundaries of each discrete income year, Australian taxpayers engaging Research Service Providers or related-party contractors must ensure that legal agreements, statements of work, invoices, intellectual property title, and experimental records are precisely aligned with the registered activities and executed contemporaneously within the relevant financial year3.

Posted on Google Google
Daniel McGregor  profile picture
Daniel McGregor
11. August, 2022
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
I have been using Swanson Reed for my clients for more than a decade. Having a specialist firm that can provide practical and commercial advice that produces real outcomes is very important and we have received great feedback from our clients. Highly recommended.
Posted on Google Google
John  profile picture
John
15. June, 2022
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Damian and the rest of the team at Swanson Reed have been supporting us for several years. We always appreciate their insights, expertise, and efforts.
Posted on Google Google
Rueben Rajasingam  profile picture
Rueben Rajasingam
6. June, 2022
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Experienced responsive Team. They have been a great help to me and my company navigate the R&D tax claim process and have provided invaluable advice.
Posted on Google Google
Enrique Esquivel  profile picture
Enrique Esquivel
6. June, 2022
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Damian and the team at Swanson Reed have been extremely helpfully and professional during all of our consultations. Highly recommended.
Posted on Google Google
Jess at Y&C  profile picture
Jess at Y&C
3. June, 2022
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Posted on Google Google
Anatole Kononewsky  profile picture
Anatole Kononewsky
2. June, 2022
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
The Swanson Reed team have provided our company with exceptional professional advice and assistance for all of our R&D claims for many years - have always achieved great results with excellent value for their services.
Posted on Google Google
Payam Toloo  profile picture
Payam Toloo
2. June, 2022
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Damian Smyth and his team are very helpful, supportive and experts in their field of R&D Tax claims. I'm always happy with the work they do and been a customer of their for over 5 years.
Posted on Google Google
Melissa Doddy  profile picture
Melissa Doddy
31. May, 2022
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
The Team at Swanson Reed are very experienced R&D Tax Advisors and gave us ongoing support with all of our R&D Claims, the consultants ensured we were always working with current legislative guidelines, gave us assistance with compiling technical and government documentation and went out their way to ensure they were with us for the entire process from beginning to end. Highly recommended to anyone who needs assistance with working through what can at times be a daunting process.
Posted on Google Google
Gary Watson  profile picture
Gary Watson
31. May, 2022
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
We can highly recommend Swanson and Reed as an R & D accountant. We have worked with them for several years now as they make our R & D claim so easy and communicate quickly with both us and our accountant.
Posted on Google Google
Rob van den Bergh  profile picture
Rob van den Bergh
31. May, 2022
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Always professional.